The Old Way

In 1878, Colton Briggs becomes part of an extrajudicial posse tasked with capturing Walter McAllister, a notorious bandit. This decision marks the beginning of a series of violent events that will forever alter the lives of those involved.

The plans for Walter’s execution devolve into chaos when he and his gang attempt to rescue him. A relentless gunfight ensues, resulting in heavy casualties, with only Colton and Walter's son, James, managing to survive the brutality.

In the aftermath of the shootout, Colton promises to spare Walter's brother, using the execution as bait to draw Walter out. This moment foreshadows the complex relationship between Colton and the McAllister family.

Consumed by rage over his father's plight, James attempts to ambush Colton but meets a swift end. This event leaves a deep impression on young James, shaping his future decisions and actions.

Fast forward twenty years, Colton has abandoned his gunfighter ways after marrying Ruth and starting a new life. However, the shadows of his violent past linger on, especially in the rebellious nature of their daughter, Brooke.

Colton's peaceful life is shattered when James McAllister returns with his gang. In a brutal attack on their farm, Ruth is murdered, and a taunting message is left behind, sending Colton into a spiral of grief.

In the midst of their mourning, Colton and Brooke encounter Franklin Jarret, the U.S. Marshal. Jarret praises Colton for leaving behind violence but warns him against seeking revenge, highlighting the internal struggle Colton faces.

Ignoring Jarret's well-meaning advice, vengeance overtakes Colton. He decides to take Brooke along and puts on his old gunfighter attire, symbolizing his return to a violent life as he sets their home ablaze.

Colton and Brooke learn that James is headed to Santa Rosa, Colorado, to retrieve a hidden stash of pesos. Armed with this knowledge, Colton sets out determined to confront James and avenge Ruth's death.

While Colton waits outside in Santa Rosa, Brooke attempts to gather information from a shopkeeper. Unfortunately, she is captured by James, heightening the stakes for Colton as he prepares to confront his nemesis.

In a tense showdown, Colton faces off against James and his gang. James offers him a horrific choice: kill him and lose Brooke, or sacrifice himself, testing Colton's resolve and commitment to his daughter.

As Colton takes a bullet from James, Brooke, having secretly honed her shooting skills, bravely picks up her father's gun. She avenges her father by killing James, showcasing her growth and determination.

Following the chaos, Franklin Jarret arrives at the scene. To protect Colton’s legacy, he concocts a cover story claiming that Colton died heroically while apprehending criminals, highlighting the dichotomy of truth and heroism.

Unbeknownst to Jarret, Brooke cleverly conceals a significant amount of the McAllister gang’s money. With a newfound resolve, she sets her sights on returning home, leaving an air of mystery about her future.