Bloody Crayons (2017) Timeline Explained – Every Event in Order

Olivia orchestrated the killings because she discovered Kenly was cheating on her with Marie. She planned to kill only Kenly, Marie, and herself as revenge for the betrayal. However, the situation spiraled out of control, leading to additional deaths that she claims were not part of her original plan.

Foreshadowing: Olivia's blue crayon confession about sleeping with Kenly during the Bloody Crayons game reveals the depth of her emotional turmoil and sets her vendetta in motion.

• olivia
• killer
• motivation
• revenge
• cheating
• kenly
• marie

Marie drew the final red crayon, which required her to drink a mixture prepared by the other players. The drink was poisoned, causing her to vomit blood and die on the spot. Olivia, who orchestrated the game, had likely poisoned the red crayon mixture as part of her revenge plan.

Foreshadowing: The Bloody Crayons game itself was Olivia's mechanism to carry out her revenge, with the red crayon representing the deadly consequence she designed.

• marie
• red crayon
• poison
• bloody crayons
• death
• game

Olivia did not actually fall to her death during the initial incident. The timeline shows she appeared to fall off the cliff during the chaos, but she survived and returned to the house alive. When John discovered the pit near the cliff, her body was missing, indicating she had survived the fall and recovered before confronting the others.

Foreshadowing: The absence of Olivia's body at the cliff where she supposedly fell is an early hint that she may have survived.

• olivia
• cliff
• survival
• fake death
• body

Olivia killed Kenly. After the chaos of Marie's death and Olivia's apparent fall, Kenly was tied up by Kiko and John to prevent further conflict. Later, he was found murdered with his throat slit. Olivia later revealed she was the mastermind behind the killings, confirming she was responsible for Kenly's death.

Foreshadowing: Olivia's confession that she planned to kill Kenly as part of her revenge confirms his killer.

• kenly
• throat slit
• killed
• murder
• olivia

Bloody Crayons is a twisted version of truth or dare played with colored crayons. Each color represents a different challenge or consequence. Red crayons require the last drawer to consume a drink mixed by the other players. The game escalates tensions among the friends and serves as Olivia's mechanism to carry out her revenge plot.

Foreshadowing: The game is introduced as entertainment during the storm, but quickly becomes the catalyst for the murders.

• bloody crayons
• game
• rules
• red crayon
• truth or dare

Olivia targeted Marie because Marie was having an affair with Kenly, Olivia's boyfriend. When Olivia discovered the infidelity, she decided Marie had to die as part of her revenge plan alongside Kenly. Marie's death via the red crayon was deliberate and planned by Olivia.

Foreshadowing: The revelation that Marie was Kenly's lover, combined with Olivia's knowledge of the affair, provides clear motive for her targeting Marie.

• marie
• targeted
• killing
• motive
• affair
• kenly

John survived being shot because he was wearing a bullet-stopping dog tag that blocked the bullet. This detail is revealed at the end when John helps Eunice escape the island after Olivia's defeat. The dog tag serves as the reason John is able to survive and assist Eunice in the final escape.

Foreshadowing: John's possession of Mang Pedring's keys and his knowledge of the island's traps suggest he had prepared for dangerous situations.

• john
• bullet
• dog tag
• survival
• shot
• escape

The masked killer chasing Eunice and Richalaine was likely Olivia herself or someone acting under her direction. The costume added an element of terror and anonymity to the attacks. Since Olivia orchestrated most of the deaths and was hunting the survivors throughout the night, she is the most probable identity of the masked figure.

Foreshadowing: The masked attacks occur after Olivia's apparent death, suggesting she faked her demise to continue her killing spree.

• masked killer
• costume
• hunt
• eunice
• richalaine
• olivia

Olivia likely faked her death at the cliff to eliminate suspicion and allow herself to continue killing without being caught. By appearing to die in an accident, she could operate in the shadows while the survivors turned on each other. This also allowed her to later return and finish her plan to kill Eunice.

Foreshadowing: Olivia's disappearance after the cliff incident and her unexpected alive appearance at the house directly contradicts the initial reports of her death.

• olivia
• fake death
• cliff
• trap
• survival

Kiko was stabbed by Olivia when he tried to warn Eunice about her suspicious behavior. Despite being severely wounded, Kiko survived long enough to communicate with Eunice and John via walkie-talkie at the end. His weak voice is heard calling for help as Eunice and John escape the island together.

Foreshadowing: Kiko's suspicion of Olivia after her return and his attempt to protect Eunice foreshadow his attack.

• kiko
• stabbed
• wounded
• survive
• eunice
• olivia

Justin became deranged due to the extreme psychological trauma of the night. After accidentally shooting Gerard during the gunfight chaos, Justin descended into madness. He attacked Richalaine and Eunice with a knife, leading to a struggle that resulted in both Justin and Richalaine falling down the stairs to their deaths.

Foreshadowing: Justin'sgression from panic to aggression is shown through his grabbing of the gun and accusatory behavior during the escalating violence.

• justin
• deranged
• madness
• attack
• psychological
• trauma

Mang Pedring was the eerie caretaker of Olivia's parents' summer home. John claimed Pedring died in a trap, which gave John access to the caretaker's keys. The specific details of Pedring's death remain somewhat unclear, but his keys proved important for John's movements around the island.

Foreshadowing: John's possession of Mang Pedring's keys raises early suspicion about his true nature and knowledge of the island.

• mang pedring
• caretaker
• keys
• death
• trap
• john

Olivia tried to kill Eunice because Eunice was the last remaining friend who knew about the cheating scandal and represented everything Olivia had lost. Although Olivia claimed she only planned to kill Kenly, Marie, and herself, she became obsessed with eliminating all witnesses to her betrayal and humiliation. Eunice's survival threatened Olivia's secrets.

Foreshadowing: Eunice's knowledge of the affair (which she kept hidden from Olivia) and her position as the final survivor made her a target.

• olivia
• eunice
• kill
• target
• final showdown