All Good Things

In the vibrant 1970s New York City, David Marks, son of a powerful real estate developer, makes a bold choice by marrying Katie McCarthy. Katie comes from a modest background, and their union reflects a mix of ambition and unconventional decision-making amid societal expectations.

David and Katie relocate to Vermont, seeking a fresh start away from the chaos of the city. They open 'All Good Things,' a health food store that exemplifies their commitment to a healthier lifestyle and their dreams as a couple.

David's father, Sanford Marks, employs manipulative tactics that draw David back into the hectic life of New York City. This influence creates tension between David and Katie, particularly as doubts arise about Katie's lifestyle choices and their direction as a couple.

Katie reveals her longing to start a family, which David resolutely refuses, leading to major misunderstandings. This lack of communication spirals out of control, as Katie mistakenly believes David may have fertility issues, intensifying the strain on their marriage.

The couple purchases a lakeside retreat in hopes of solidifying their future together. It is here that Katie shares her unexpected pregnancy with their neighbor, but David's reaction is anything but supportive, leading to dramatic consequences.

When Katie discloses her pregnancy, David reacts explosively, demanding she terminate the pregnancy. Reluctantly, Katie complies with his wishes, marking a pivotal moment in their relationship as trust and hope begin to erode.

In her pursuit of a medical degree, Katie enrolls in school, combating the increasing strain on her marriage. David’s opposition to her educational ambitions grows, especially as he restricts her access to financial resources, driving a wedge between them.

Desperate to reclaim her independence, Katie embarks on a quest to find incriminating evidence against David. She digs into financial records to leverage her position in a marriage that feels increasingly suffocating and dangerous.

Tragedy strikes in 1982 when Katie goes missing under mysterious circumstances, leaving behind only a alluring clue and a $15,000 reward for information. The sudden loss raises questions about her fate and the dynamics of her troubled marriage to David.

Eighteen years later, the investigation into Katie's disappearance is reignited following the discovery of a novel penned by David's best friend, Deborah Lehrman. The novel eerily parallels Katie’s fate, renewing scrutiny on David and his past.

Investigators discover unsettling connections between David and the murder of his neighbor, Malvern Bump, in Texas. Although David is acquitted, the allegations linger, casting a shadow over his character and fueling public intrigue regarding Katie’s fate.

Despite David's acquittal, the mystery surrounding Katie's disappearance continues to captivate both the authorities and the general public. The case evolves into a haunting enigma, drawing attention and speculation in the media.

In a chilling flashback, it is suggested that David may have secretly stored Katie's remains in the trunk of her car, raising unsettling implications. This discovery stirs further mystery and guilt, hinting at his complicated relationship with both Katie and family.

In a poignant moment, David visits his ailing father and expresses deep sorrow with the haunting words, 'I miss her so much.' This ambiguous statement leaves audiences questioning the underlying emotions tied to Katie's disappearance.