Three Christs

In 1954, Dr. Alan Stone made a significant decision to leave his studies at New York University. This marked the beginning of his journey into the Ypsilanti State Mental Asylum, where he aimed to explore the treatment of schizophrenic patients.

Upon entering the asylum, Dr. Stone quickly established himself as a critic of the harsh mental health practices of the time. The prevalent methods, such as insulin shock and electroconvulsive therapy, were viewed unfavorably by Stone, who believed in the power of compassionate treatment over physical punishments.

During his tenure, Stone met two captivating patients, both claiming to be Jesus Christ. Joseph Cassell, an intelligent man, and Clyde Benson, a troubled soul, became the focal point of his therapeutic exploration, presenting unique challenges that would shape his approach.

Inspired by his interactions, Dr. Stone introduced innovative group talk therapy to the asylum. He included Leon Gabor, another patient who believed in his divinity, which allowed Stone to further explore the psychological dynamics between these three individuals.

Through his method, Stone uncovered the deeply embedded traumas of his patients. Gabor's issues stemmed from an oppressive upbringing and military assaults, Benson's grief from his wife’s death and abortion, and Cassell's struggles with violent impulses heightened by his past treatments.

Dr. Stone began to earn accolades for his revolutionary treatment methods, even gracing the cover of a prominent medical journal. This recognition, however, was met with concern from his peers, particularly Dr. Orbus, whose credentials were closely linked to the older, less compassionate methods.

Feeling threatened by Stone's success, Dr. Orbus attempted to interfere with Cassell's therapy sessions, much to Stone's frustration. Orbus's manipulative tactics became evident when Cassell realized the head psychiatrist's true intentions fell short of helping him.

After experiencing Dr. Orbus’s betrayal, Cassell fell into despair, resulting in volatile outbursts. Orbus responded by reinstating aggressive electroshock therapies that Stone had been fighting against, further complicating matters.

Stone attempted to protect Cassell from the escalating emotional turmoil but faced resistance. This conflict culminated in a physical confrontation with another physician, leading to injuries on both sides and further deterioration of the asylum's atmosphere.

Ultimately, Dr. Orbus ousted Dr. Stone from the asylum. This betrayal left Stone feeling defeated, yet he remained steadfast in his belief in compassionate care despite the harsh realities imposed by Orbus.

Under Orbus’s manipulation, Cassell began viewing Stone as an adversary rather than an ally. In a heartbreaking moment of clarity, he saw through the psychiatrist's intentions and plunged into despair, culminating in a tragic leap from the chapel bell tower.

Cassell’s devastating death prompted an official hearing where Dr. Stone testified against Dr. Orbus. Stone interpreted Cassell's final actions as a profound commentary on struggle and sacrifice, ultimately shifting the focus onto the systemic failures of mental healthcare.

Following the hearing, Dr. Stone was dismissed from his position but was granted permission to continue his research in New York, along with some of his surviving patients. This move signified a bittersweet victory for Stone, as he left the oppressive environment behind.

While Dr. Stone moved on, Dr. Orbus’s reign of terror was curtailed, leading to his eventual retirement. The systemic issues of the asylum remained, but Orbus's credibility began to dwindle significantly.

In the film's closing moments, Dr. Stone is seen sitting with Cassell and Benson, engaged in a peaceful game of cards. This scene serves as a powerful reminder of hope and the potential for healing amidst loss and suffering.