Ray Eames has spent seven years on death row for the shooting of policeman Jackie McGrath in a drug-bust gone wrong, and as his electrocution is finally scheduled, his last request is simple: someone to photograph his death. Paul Marish reluctantly takes on the assignment. At the airport he meets Jake Rusher, McGrath’s former partner, who urges him not to document the event—that the image would reopen old wounds and re-traumatize a town trying to move on.
On the day of the scheduled execution, Marish visits the inmate as his head is shaved and he’s led to the electric chair, blindfolded. Yet at the last moment a reprieve is ordered, and Marish walks out of the prison past a chorus of sign-wavers, protesters, and counter-protesters. Back home, Jake Rusher returns to his exotic-pet store, frees the animals, and writes "NO JUSTICE" on a crime-scene photograph before shooting himself.
Dan Weston, a Time reporter, arrives to help tell the story. He and Marish visit McGrath’s widow, Hannah McGrath, and they’re there when she and police officer Jerry Brown receive word that Rusher has killed himself. The investigators also speak with the D.A., Steve March, who defends the official line that crimes like Eames’ are “why the death penalty was invented.” Marish challenges him, saying, “you scare me a hell of a lot more than he does”; the moment leads to their ejection from March’s office.
Eames’ latest reprieve expires, and the mystery deepens as Marish wonders why Rusher would be driven to suicide. A personal connection emerges as a romance begins to blossom between Marish and Hannah. When Marish examines the crime-scene photograph, he notices it was reversed, suggesting the bullet that killed McGrath might have come from a different direction. This discovery stirs the growing suspicion that Eames did not pull the trigger.
Further revelations come from Mike Knighton, the assistant D.A., who explains that Eames’ partner Floyd Tatum had been a confidential informant and that Knighton himself killed Tatum years earlier. Hannah and Marish track Tatum down; he refuses to testify, but Marish secretly records his confession. Tatum admits that Knighton, Rusher, and he were involved in drug trafficking, and McGrath had stumbled onto the scheme and tried to stop them—placing Eames in as a patsy. Hannah also confesses she had an affair with Rusher, providing him another motive to remove her husband.
With the town already at the edge of its patience, evening falls on the execution again. Hannah and Marish hurry back to town to reveal the taped confession to D.A. March and Judge Harold Landis. Landis, however, refuses to grant Eames another trial, calling the new evidence “hearsay.” The scene at the jail grows frantic as Marish tries to intervene in the execution, shouting and pounding on the glass. It takes two electrical charges to end Eames’ life, and only after the final jolt does Landis call in a reprieve—too late. Marish documents the stunned warden and the crowd’s mixed reactions, exiting the prison to a city split between fireworks and candlelit protests.
In the aftermath, the film renders a portrait of a town wrestling with truth, memory, and the price of justice, where the line between right and wrong is tested by records, confessions, and the relentless pursuit of accountability.
