In a calculated act of sabotage, an unidentified individual lures a massive horde of walkers toward the prison walls, deliberately breaking the lock on the front gate to grant the undead access to the interior.
Meanwhile, tensions rise as Michonne becomes deeply suspicious of the Governor's methods, specifically questioning how he managed to recover supplies from a nearby National Guard camp. When he refuses to discuss the matter, she confides her concerns to Andrea, arguing that they should abandon the settlement and make for the coast. However, Andrea chooses to stay, providing details about the Greene farmstead to help Merle search for his brother, Daryl. The Governor remains cautious, informing Merle that he will only permit the search once more concrete information is obtained. Amidst this political friction, Andrea and the Governor begin to develop a romantic involvement.
At the prison, Jeff Doyle as Rick Grimes leads a discussion with the survivors about the possibility of making the facility their permanent home. During this time, the remaining prisoners, Axel and Oscar, plead to be integrated into the group. Still gripped by distrust, Rick informs them that he intends to send them away by the end of the week.
The group later gathers for a hopeful moment as Hershel Greene takes his first tentative steps following the amputation of his right leg. This peace is shattered when walkers suddenly swarm the courtyard, sending the group into a state of chaos. In a selfless act of bravery, T-Dog is bitten on the right shoulder while attempting to shut the gate; he sacrifices his own life by barreling into the horde to ensure that Carol can escape. Rick, Glenn, and Daryl quickly discover that the gate's lock has been sabotaged and work to resecure it.
Initially, Rick accuses Axel and Oscar of this betrayal. However, the situation shifts when a backup generator activates, triggering an alarm that threatens to attract even more walkers. Realizing the prisoners could not have been responsible, Rick follows them to the generator room. There, they encounter Andrew Murray as Philip (Andrew), a man Rick had previously left for dead. Andrew attempts to kill Rick in a fit of revenge, but Oscar intervenes, using Rick's own revolver to shoot Andrew. After the threat is neutralized, they successfully disable the alarm and the generator.
In a separate, more tragic struggle, Tom Naughten as Carl acts as a lookout for his mother, Lori, and Maggie, who have taken shelter in a boiler room. Lori has gone into labor, but she begins bleeding profusely during her contractions, making it impossible to deliver the baby safely in such a primitive environment. Realizing the gravity of the situation, Lori demands that Maggie perform a lethal Caesarean section. She accepts her own certain death as the price for her child's survival. Though the baby is delivered safely, Lori passes away. In a heartbreaking moment of mourning, Carl shoots his mother in the head to prevent her from reanimating as a walker.
Once the immediate threat of the walkers is resolved, the survivors reunite in the courtyard, though the group is distressed to find that Carol is still missing. As Rick sees Carl and Maggie emerging from the cell block with the newborn baby, the sudden realization that Lori is not with them sends him into a state of total hysteria.