Hamlet

Dana Marschz, a failed actor and recovering alcoholic, becomes a high school drama teacher in Tucson, Arizona. He has a history of producing poorly received school plays, often adaptations of popular Hollywood films, including his latest production of Erin Brockovich. Despite considering himself an inspirational figure, he struggles to gain enthusiasm from his students.

At the start of the new school term, a fresh batch of students transfer into Dana's drama class due to budget cuts, despite being unenthusiastic about arts education. Dana comes into conflict with Octavio, one of the new students, questioning his authority and approach. The class shows little interest in drama, making Dana feel discouraged.

Principal Rocker informs Dana that the school's drama program will be shut down at the end of the term owing to budget issues. This news motivates Dana to find a way to revitalize the program and prove its worth, despite the bleak outlook.

Dana decides to write and produce an original stage play, a sequel to Hamlet with a twist involving time travel to avoid character deaths. The script also introduces controversial content, including a musical segment featuring Jesus Christ, with the song 'Rock Me Sexy Jesus'. His students start warming up to the project as it gains momentum.

Tensions arise when Rand storms out of the drama group after being cast as Laertes, feeling overshadowed by Octavio's portrayal of Hamlet. Rand leaks the script to Principal Rocker, leading to a directive to halt the production. Despite this, the project continues secretly.

Dana's personal life hits a low point when his wife Brie leaves him for a more attractive boarder named Gary. She also reveals that Dana is infertile, which deeply affects him. These events push Dana toward despair, leading him to relapse into alcoholism.

Despite Dana's struggles, his students encourage him to continue the play. They organize a secret rehearsal space in an abandoned warehouse, providing technical and security support from the school's football and wrestling teams. This teamwork revives Dana's resolve to see the project through.

The controversial play is performed in a sold-out venue, attracting media attention and a critic from The New York Times. The cancellation of the play becomes a civil liberties issue, advocated by radical ACLU activist Cricket Feldstein, resulting in wider support to keep the play running despite protests.

Initially met with mixed reactions due to its controversial content and chaotic execution, the play begins to win over the audience as it explores themes of forgiveness and reconciliation through time travel. Protesters infiltrate the audience, but the play ultimately gains acceptance and appreciation.

The play concludes with Hamlet and Jesus forgiving their fathers, symbolizing reconciliation. Dana, now dating actress Elisabeth Shue, meets with his students to prepare for a Broadway opening, indicating a career shift and personal growth.