South Florida becomes the tense backdrop for a troubling true‑crime tale about four teens who drift into violence. In this story, Ali Willis and Lisa Connelly—two South Florida high school dropouts—befriend two local deli workers, Nick Stahl as Bobby Kent and Brad Renfro as Marty Puccio, and they all end up on a troubling double date that foreshadows a much darker road ahead. The evening unfolds in the car: Ali engages in oral sex with Bobby while Lisa and Marty, who is Marty Puccio, share a private moment in the back seat. What begins as a casual night quickly spirals as Lisa learns she is pregnant, and the frightening reality surfaces that the child’s paternity might fall to Bobby rather than Marty after Bobby brutalizes and rapes Lisa.
From there, the dynamics grow darker. Bobby’s hold on Marty intensifies, both emotionally and physically, and the abuse becomes a grim pattern that leaves Marty reeling. The violence doesn’t stop there: Bobby rapes Ali while forcing her to watch explicit material, an act that underscores the coercive power he holds over the group. Lisa wrestles with the weight of these revelations as rumors start to swirl about Bobby’s true attraction toward Marty, deepening the group’s sense of danger and complicity. Marty opens up about a painful past—the abuse that began when they were younger and the drugs that tainted those early years—which he suspects Bobby exploited to keep him under control. A night out at a gay bar later exposes more of the group’s humiliation and powerlessness, as Marty is forced to strip down and perform for money, and Bobby seems to revel in the degradation.
As fear and resentment fester, Lisa proposes a drastic solution: they should murder Bobby. Ali brings in her new circle—Donny Semenec, who uses pot and acid, and Heather Swallers, recently released from rehab—while Lisa recruits her cousin Derek Dzvirko, a shy, bookish presence who becomes entwined in the plan. Their initial approach uses a gun stolen from Lisa’s mother, a plan that never comes to fruition. The group then pivots, seeking professional help of sorts by hiring a supposed “hitman” and Ali’s friend Derek Kaufman to execute the killing.
A revised plan is set in motion: the group drives to the Everglades again, and Ali lures Bobby to the canal bank with the promise of sex. Heather’s signal cue triggers the assault: Donny slips up behind Bobby and stabs him in the neck. In a moment of horror, Ali, Heather, and Dzvirko sprint back to the car while Lisa watches as Marty and Donny stab Bobby repeatedly and slash his throat, and Kaufman uses a baseball bat to finalize the death. They drag the dying Bobby into the swamp, hoping alligators will finish the job. The grim scene leaves them shaken, yet they move quickly to cover their tracks, discarding the diving knife sheath that could tie them to the crime.
With the immediate danger of discovery looming, Dzvirko and Lisa confess bits of what happened to a few friends, but the others still cling to the belief that they did not directly kill Bobby. Ali, meanwhile, makes an anonymous tip to the media, turning up the heat on the investigation. Lisa calls Kaufman and learns he has already been arrested, a turn of events that accelerates the unraveling. In time, almost everyone involved chooses to surrender, with Marty the notable exception who is eventually taken into custody. The courtroom becomes the final stage for the group, where they appear in prison jumpsuits and deny culpability even as the consequences of their actions loom large.
The narrative closes with stark, real‑world consequences: Derek Kaufman, Donny Semenec, and Lisa Connelly receive life sentences; Ali Willis is sentenced to 40 years; Derek Dzvirko gets 11 years, Heather Swallers seven years, and Marty Puccio receives the death penalty, which would be vacated in 1997. The film ends by grounding the events in their enduring outcomes, emphasizing how a summer of recklessness gave way to years of punishment and reflection for those involved.
This retelling stays true to the emotional currents and sequence of events: camaraderie and curiosity among teens becoming a corridor to coercion, manipulation, and a chilling murder, followed by confession, legal reckoning, and the heavy, lasting imprint of a crime that forever marks the lives of those who survived the choices of that long-ago night.
