Tough Guys Don’t Dance

In the present, Tim is visited by his father Dougy, who reveals he has stopped chemotherapy with the blunt line that 'tough guys don't dance.' Tim admits there are parts of two murdered bodies in his cellar and that he has been experiencing blackouts and hallucinations. The tense exchange sets up the layer of guilt and danger surrounding his home.

Tim wakes up after a drug-fueled night involving cocaine and sex with Jessica Pond, in front of Lonnie Pangborn. He discovers bloody clothing in his car and a tattoo bearing Madeleine Falco’s name. Regency warns him to clear his marijuana stash from the woods before the state troopers discover it, and soon a severed head is found under the drugs, with Lonnie dead and Jessica missing.

Tim remembers meeting Madeleine Falco when he was a bartender, a memory that anchors the drama in past relationships. This recollection introduces Madeleine as a pivotal connection before the plot thickens with Patty and Big Stoop. The memory hints at the tangled loyalties that follow Tim.

Tim recalls meeting Patty after he encouraged Madeleine to go swinging with Patty and her then-husband Big Stoop. Patty expresses ambition, hinting she’ll pursue a richer life, a motive that threads through the subsequent power plays. This memory lays the groundwork for the opportunistic network around Tim.

Patty promises a path to wealth: divorce Big Stoop, marry a rich man, and then wed Tim so he can chase his writing dreams. The prospect reveals her calculating approach and the transactional nature of the relationships surrounding Tim. The seed of manipulation is firmly planted in Tim’s life.

During a tense trip back, Tim and Madeleine argue, and their car crashes. The accident leaves Madeleine infertile, creating a permanent scar on their relationship and raising the stakes for both. The crash deepens Tim’s sense of loss and the consequences of the entangled past.

Tim spends time in prison for dealing cocaine, and upon release, Patty has married Wardley Meeks III, who hires Tim as Patty’s chauffeur. This arrangement tightens Tim’s ties to Wardley’s wealth and the criminal web surrounding them. The new dynamic foreshadows the mounting pressure and deception.

Patty files for divorce from Wardley, and Tim testifies to help her secure a large settlement. The courtroom moment tests Tim’s loyalties and pits his own interests against Patty’s scheme-driven ambitions. The legal maneuvering marks a turning point in the manipulation web.

Tim reunites with Madeleine, who reveals Regency is involved with Patty and hints at a murder plot. Regency claims Jessica and Lonnie were sent to Provincetown with $2 million to buy cocaine from Tim, an accusation designed to frame him further. The tension escalates as old betrayals come to a head.

Tim checks his stash again and finds two severed heads waiting for him. On the way back, he is assaulted by his friends Spider and Stoodie but manages to escape with the heads. The discovery compounds the mounting danger and the sense that nobody is safe.

Wardley abducts Tim at gunpoint and takes him to Helltown, where he outlines his side of the story. He explains the blackmail, the scams involving Patty and Regency, and the betrayals that culminate in tragedy. The confrontation reframes Tim’s understanding of who harmed whom.

Tim returns home to Madeleine waiting outside, and they share a kiss as the truth about Patty and Regency’s schemes becomes clearer. Regency, drunk, confesses to framing Tim, then suffers a stroke, and Madeleine shoots Regency in a final act of justice. The film closes with Tim and Madeleine disposing of the remaining bodies at sea and Madeleine using the $2 million to buy a house for them, signaling a fragile new beginning.