Deception 5 steps
Deacon's Fabricated Closure: Erasing Sparma and Planting the Red Barrette
After Baxter kills Sparma, Deacon destroys the physical evidence of Sparma's existence and then mails Baxter a fabricated red barrette, a false piece of evidence whose purpose is to convince Baxter that Sparma was the killer and that he did not kill an innocent man.
Read the 5 steps as text
- 1
Baxter murders Sparma
Jim Baxter · Albert Sparma
Baxter murders Sparma in a moment of intense frustration and doubt, creating the situation Deacon then moves to cover up.
- 2
Deacon burns the evidence
Joe 'Deke' Deacon · Albert Sparma
Deacon intervenes to help Baxter cover his tracks by erasing Sparma's entire existence, burning the evidence connected to him.
- 3
Deacon gives Baxter a false sense of closure
Joe 'Deke' Deacon · Jim Baxter
What it looked like: Baxter is led to feel the matter is resolved, when the closure rests on destroyed evidence rather than established fact.
By erasing Sparma's existence, Deacon gives Baxter a false sense of closure over the killing, removing the immediate trail that could sustain doubt or guilt.
- 4
Deacon sends the fabricated red barrette
Joe 'Deke' Deacon · Jim Baxter
What it looked like: The barrette appears to be genuine evidence tying Sparma to the crimes, when it is actually fabricated by Deacon.
Deacon sends Baxter a seemingly relevant but ultimately fabricated piece of evidence, a red barrette, designed to convince him that he did not kill an innocent man.
- 5
Baxter is convinced he didn't kill an innocent man
Jim Baxter · Joe 'Deke' Deacon
The deception succeeds in its aim: Baxter is protected from guilt and the cycle of obsession that plagued Deacon, believing Sparma was guilty.
