The Way We Weren’t

1937, a crossroads of passion and principle unfolds as two college students from starkly different worlds cross paths: a staunch Marxist Jew named Katie Morosky and a carefree WASP named Hubbell Gardiner. Katie’s fierce commitment to social causes and anti-war ideals stands in sharp contrast to Hubbell’s easygoing charm and talent for writing. As they get to know one another, Katie admires Hubbell’s looks and wit, while Hubbell is drawn to Katie’s unwavering conviction. Their unlikely pairing is met with skepticism from Hubbell’s circle, who tease Katie’s political stances and lifestyle. Their brief moment of closeness culminates in a long, glorious dance at the senior prom, a sign of chemistry that fate will repeatedly test, before they drift apart.

Fast forward to New York City near the end of World War II, where time and circumstance bring them back into each other’s orbit. Katie is juggling multiple jobs, while Hubbell returns from active duty in the South Pacific as a naval officer, carrying with him stories from the front and the weight of his own comfortable, apolitical orbit. The spark rekindles into a deeper bond, and they fall in love. The momentous era that follows carries the weight of public life and private longing, especially after the death of President Franklin D. Roosevelt. Katie’s indignation toward Hubbell’s friends who crack jokes at her expense clashes with Hubbell’s growing sense of frustration at Katie’s blunt candor and his own reluctance to fully engage with the political storms around them. What begins as a tender romance evolves into a complicated dynamic: Hubbell backs away, and they briefly part, only to eventually reunite.

As their relationship grows more complicated, Hubbell receives an opportunity to adapt his novel into a screenplay. Katie worries that Hollywood might squander his talent, but the couple moves to Malibu, drawn by the glimmer of a film industry lifestyle and the security it promises. It is during this relocation that a revelation sinks in: in the bustle of unpacking, they discover they have already married, sealing their commitment in a world that feels bright yet precarious. The glamour of their new life—furnished by studio contracts and coastal living—shadows the creeping dawn of fear and suspicion that would soon define a nation.

The creeping shadow is the Hollywood blacklist and the rise of McCarthyism, which begin to touch even the couple’s carefully constructed world. Katie’s activist instincts flare anew, pushing against a system that threatens personal privacy and free speech. The clash between her principled stances and Hubbell’s desire for a more secluded, career-centered life strains their marriage. Katie’s pregnancy marks a hopeful milestone, yet it is followed by heartbreak: Hubbell’s affair with a former college girlfriend reveals the limits of what he’s willing to give, and the distance between their dreams becomes increasingly hard to bridge. Katie comes to see that Hubbell may never be the partner she imagined possible, and the emotional toll leaves him exhausted, unable to meet her expectations.

The arrival of their daughter, whom Katie names Rachel, becomes a defining moment. The couple ultimately decides to part ways, their marriage dissolving under the pressure of conflicting values and ambitions. Years pass, and destiny nudges them back into each other’s orbit, briefly and poignantly, in front of the Plaza Hotel in New York City. Katie, a persistent advocate for change, is demonstrating to ban the bomb when a taxi interrupts the moment they almost reconnect. The farewell is tender, bittersweet, and honest—a quiet acknowledgment that the love they shared was real, even if their paths diverged.

In the grand arc of their lives, the story traces the pull between idealism and practicality, love and duty, and the personal costs of standing in the public arena. The timeline—from their fraying youth in the 1930s to the later confrontations with censorship and war-era anxieties—paints a portrait of two people who collide, connect, and ultimately learn to navigate the world on terms that feel true to themselves, even as they walk separate roads. The film remains a nuanced meditation on memory, resilience, and the enduring question of what it means to love in a world that continually tests one’s beliefs.

Last Updated: October 01, 2025 at 13:04