The Threesome (2025) Timeline Explained – Every Event in Order

After Olivia panicked about her emotional attachment and left Connor's apartment at dawn, Connor was left feeling rejected and vulnerable. He ended up sleeping with Jenny, who was still at his place from earlier that night. This was a moment of emotional weakness rather than deliberate choice, as Connor had genuine feelings for Olivia and would later pursue a relationship with her.

• connor
• jenny
• threesome
• emotional decision
• vulnerability

Olivia was devastated to learn that Connor had gotten Jenny pregnant from their one-night encounter. The timing was especially painful since Connor had just convinced Olivia to give their relationship a real chance. Olivia felt she could not build a future with someone who had already fathered a child with another woman, leading her to end the romance and plan an abortion.

• olivia
• jenny
• pregnancy
• breakup
• connor
• betrayal

While driving back from the abortion appointment, Connor saw a text from a former partner of Olivia's. The message revealed that Olivia had been seeking closure with this ex rather than working through their issues together. Feeling betrayed and hurt that Olivia had not been fully committed to their relationship, Connor ended things despite the emotional reconnection they had experienced during the trip.

• conor
• olivia
• breakup
• text message
• betrayal
• road trip

During the road trip to the out-of-state abortion clinic, the emotional intimacy between Olivia and Connor rekindled their connection. As they spent time together and Olivia felt their bond strengthening, she reconsidered her decision. The reawakened feelings made her want to keep the baby, and she ultimately chose to proceed with the pregnancy.

Foreshadowing: The trip was intended to end the pregnancy but instead became a moment of emotional renewal that changed Olivia's mind.

• olivia
• baby
• abortion
• decision
• road trip
• pregnancy

Olivia's married fling, not Connor, is the father of her child. The married lover had claimed to have had a vasectomy, but later revealed he never actually had the procedure. This paternity twist is revealed during the hospital scene when Connor learns he is not the father and must leave to attend Jenny's birth instead.

Foreshadowing: Earlier in the story, Olivia's married fling resurfaces and reveals he never had a vasectomy, setting up the paternity question.

• olivia
• paternity
• baby father
• vasectomy
• twist
• connor

Connor discovered through the paternity revelation that he was not the father of Olivia's child. Since Jenny was also in labor that same day and Connor was indeed the father of her baby, he left Olivia's delivery to be present for Jenny's birth. This choice prioritized his biological child while also fulfilling his commitment to Jenny.

• conor
• hospital
• birth
• jenny
• paternity
• leaving

Olivia named her daughter after Connor's maternal grandmother as a meaningful gesture of love and connection. Despite their complicated history and the revelation that Connor was not the biological father, Olivia's choice demonstrates her enduring feelings for Connor and her desire to keep a piece of him part of her life.

• olivia
• daughter
• name
• grandmother
• connor
• love

After breaking up with Olivia, Connor shifted his support to Jenny, who was pregnant with his child. He drove her to doctor appointments, including using Olivia's own doctor, and maintained the pretense of a stable couple to satisfy Jenny's parents. This choice reflected Connor's struggle between a simple, conventional life with Jenny and his lingering feelings for Olivia, though it ultimately reinforced a web of deception.

• conor
• jenny
• deception
• parents
• doctor
• support

The post-credits scene shows Greg planning to tell the story of Connor, Olivia, and Jenny during his toast at Connor and Olivia's wedding. This implies that despite all the chaos, confusion, and complications, Connor and Olivia ultimately end up together. Greg's storytelling suggests the couple is willing to face their complicated past openly and humorously as they begin their married life.

• wedding
• post-credits
• greg
• toast
• future
• resolution

After Olivia's married lover revealed he never had a vasectomy, Olivia became suspicious about the actual paternity of her child. She quietly arranged for a paternity test to determine whether Connor or her married fling was the biological father. However, labor overtook the moment before she could get definitive answers, and the truth only emerged later at the hospital.

Foreshadowing: The married fling's revelation about the vasectomy directly triggered Olivia's doubts and the secret testing plan.

• olivia
• paternity test
• vasectomy
• married lover
• investigation

During a heated argument, Olivia pointed out the unfairness of Connor having two pregnancies with different women while she looked foolish for trusting him. However, beneath her harsh words lay a deeper truth, she still loved Connor and had fantasized about rebuilding their relationship. The argument forced her to confront her true feelings, leading to the confession.

• olivia
• confession
• love
• argument
• pregnancy
• feelings

At the story's conclusion, Connor is torn between the practical co-parenting relationship he has built with Jenny and his deep emotional connection with Olivia. When Olivia arrives on moving day with their daughter and confesses her love once more, Connor chooses to explore rebuilding their relationship. This decision reflects his longstanding genuine feelings for Olivia, who was the first person to make him feel deeply.

• conor
• olivia
• jenny
• choice
• love
• relationship
• ending