The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry

Amelia Loman, a sales representative, travels to Alice Island where she meets A.J. Fikry, a depressed bookstore owner. During their encounter, she shares her admiration for a book titled 'The Late Bloomer', but A.J. dismisses her enthusiasm and the book itself.

The following day, A.J. wakes up missing his copy of 'Tamberlane' and, overwhelmed by a panic attack, believes he is dying. He visits the police station to report his missing book and meets Officer Nick Lambiase, who learns about A.J.'s troubled state after the recent loss of his wife.

While searching for help regarding his missing book, A.J. stumbles into a bookstore where he meets a two-year-old girl named Maya. Unbeknownst to him, this innocent encounter would lead him to take care of Maya for the weekend as her circumstances are dire and her parents unknown.

After a visit from social worker Jenny, A.J. learns that Maya faces the risk of being placed into foster care. Moved by her situation, he decides to adopt Maya, thereby creating an unexpected family bond. Ismay, a friend from A.J.'s past, is named her godmother.

Amelia reconnects with A.J. to discuss new books after the incident with Maya. A.J. surprises himself by enjoying 'The Late Bloomer', which Maya has started reading, and he asks Amelia out for lunch, beginning a budding friendship.

During their lunch date, A.J. and Amelia deepen their connection through discussions about literature and personal lives. Amelia reveals that she is engaged to a man in the military, complicating their evolving relationship.

Following a heartfelt conversation via video chat, A.J. visits Amelia in Providence. Their friendship quickly turns romantic when they spend a night together, marking a significant shift in both their lives.

After growing closer, A.J. proposes to Amelia, and she joyfully accepts. They begin planning a wedding on Alice Island, surrounded by their loved ones, including Maya and their friends.

On the day of the wedding, Ismay struggles with A.J.'s marriage to someone else and escapes to the ocean. Despite Lambiase’s attempt to bring her back, a tragic car accident occurs, killing Daniel and leaving Ismay injured.

Years later, a 7-year-old Maya submits a short story for a high school contest, supported by A.J., Amelia, and Lambiase. She shares her emotionally impactful story titled 'The Day at the Beach', earning third place, making her family proud.

During a routine health check, A.J. learns he has cancer, a devastating blow to him and his family. He confides in Lambiase about his condition, and the emotional weight of his illness begins to affect all his relationships.

A.J. undergoes surgery for his cancer while Maya reads to him, hoping to bring him comfort. Sadly, A.J. passes away, leaving Maya and Amelia heartbroken but with cherished memories.

The film concludes with Ismay and Lambiase contemplating taking over A.J.’s bookstore to honor his memory. Meanwhile, Amelia and Maya prepare to leave Alice Island, reflecting on their journey filled with love and loss.

With the bookstore under new stewardship, a newcomer arrives on Alice Island, reminiscent of A.J.'s first meeting with Amelia. This encounter symbolizes hope and continuity, suggesting that the influence of A.J.'s life and love will continue through others.