Plot Explained Spoilers guaranteed!
Plot Explained

Browse by genre

The Next Best Thing (2000) movie poster

Plot Summary

The Next Best Thing (2000) Plot Summary Explained

Release, runtime and language
2000 · 108 min · English
Directed by
John Schlesinger
Starring
Madonna, Rupert Everett
Budget
$25M

After experiencing heartbreak, lifelong friends Abbie and Robert find solace in each other's company, leading to an unexpected and profound connection. They embark on a journey into parenthood, facing the challenges and joys of raising a child while navigating the complexities of a same-sex relationship and confronting societal expectations. Their bond deepens as they learn to support each other through the unpredictable path ahead.

On this page (5)
  1. 1 What happens: full plot
  2. 2 Plot questions answered
  3. 3 Movie threads
  4. 4 Movies like The Next Best Thing
  5. 5 Every angle

Full plot summary · contains spoilers

What Happens in The Next Best Thing: Full Plot Summary

The whole story of The Next Best Thing (2000) explained, from the opening scene to the final frame: every key event, every twist and what it all adds up to. Read it as a quick recap before the sequel, to check a scene you missed, or to finally understand what really happened.

The film features Madonna in the role of Abbie Reynolds, a dedicated yoga instructor residing in the bustling city of New York. Alongside her is Rupert Everett, portraying Robert, her loyal gay best friend. The narrative takes a surprising turn when Abbie unexpectedly finds out she is pregnant, and she chooses to raise the child in partnership with Robert. Their profound friendship forms the foundation of this unique situation.

As Abbie’s relationship with Ben begins to blossom, Robert confronts a whirlwind of emotions including loneliness, jealousy, and confusion. His long-standing affinity for Abbie complicates their friendship, causing his feelings to teeter on the brink of romantic love. The shift in their dynamic creates a rift as Robert grapples with the fear that he is slowly losing his place in Abbie’s life, now that she is stepping into a traditional romantic role with Ben. The bond that they once cherished feels threatened, leaving Robert in a state of upheaval.

The emotional strain manifests in several conflicts, as Robert wrestles with his complicated feelings for Abbie combined with his own self-identity. He is left questioning whether he is merely a "second choice" in her life and if his love for her will ever be fully recognized or reciprocated. Meanwhile, Abbie faces her own struggles, torn between her new responsibilities as a mother and her longing for a conventional family life with Ben. She strives to maintain the cherished connection with Robert, a friendship that has always been a source of stability, while navigating the evolving dynamics that come with her new reality.

Amidst these complexities, the heart of the film remains focused on the enduring bond of friendship and the challenges it faces when confronted with love, family, and personal desires. Abbie and Robert's journey serves as a poignant exploration of the intricate balance between companionship and romantic love.

Last updated: May 12, 2025 at 07:03

Was this helpful?

Plot questions answered

The Next Best Thing Plot Explained: Your Questions Answered

The questions people ask most about The Next Best Thing (2000): what happens in the confusing scenes, why the characters do what they do, the twists, hidden details and what the ending means. Each answer contains spoilers.

Q1

Why does Abbie decide to raise the child with Robert?

Abbie chooses to raise the child with Robert because their deep friendship gives her confidence he will support her through parenthood. She trusts him completely and believes their strong bond provides a stable foundation for raising a child together, even though they are not a romantic couple.

Foreshadowing: Earlier scenes establish their close friendship and Robert's unwavering loyalty to Abbie.

  • abbie
  • robert
  • pregnancy
  • parenting
  • friendship
Q2

Why does Robert develop feelings for Abbie despite being gay?

Robert's feelings for Abbie evolve gradually from years of close friendship into romantic love. Though he identifies as gay, the film explores how his deep emotional connection with Abbie transcends his usual sexual orientation, creating complex feelings he struggles to understand and reconcile.

Foreshadowing: Robert's jealousy when Abbie begins dating Ben hints at deeper feelings beneath their friendship.

  • robert
  • abbie
  • feelings
  • love
  • gay
  • confusion
Q3

What causes the conflict between Abbie and Robert?

The conflict arises when Abbie starts dating Ben, causing Robert to feel sidelined and replaced. His long-standing romantic feelings for Abbie combine with fear of losing his place in her life, creating jealousy and emotional turmoil that strains their friendship.

Foreshadowing: Robert's growing loneliness becomes apparent as Abbie's relationship with Ben deepens.

  • conflict
  • robert
  • ben
  • jealousy
  • friendship
Q4

Why does Robert feel like a second choice?

Robert feels like a second choice because as Abbie invests more in her relationship with Ben and prepares for traditional family life, he perceives himself being pushed out of her inner circle. He fears his role as her primary emotional support is being replaced by her new romantic partner.

Foreshadowing: Robert's early jealousy when Abbie begins dating hints at his fear of replacement.

  • robert
  • second choice
  • fear
  • replacement
  • emotional support
Q5

How does the pregnancy change Abbie and Robert's friendship?

The pregnancy transforms their friendship by adding co-parenting responsibilities and forcing them to navigate new emotional territory. What was once a simple platonic bond now involves shared domestic duties, financial considerations, and discussions about the future, fundamentally altering their dynamic.

Foreshadowing: The sudden news of the pregnancy is described as changing their dynamics with those around them.

  • pregnancy
  • friendship
  • dynamic
  • parenting
  • changes
Q6

Does Abbie end up with Ben or Robert?

The film ends with Abbie and Robert redefining their relationship on new terms. While they confront their feelings for each other, the resolution emphasizes acceptance and understanding rather than a traditional romantic outcome, suggesting their bond evolves into a more nuanced partnership.

Foreshadowing: The confrontation of feelings marks a pivotal turning point where both must decide their future.

  • ending
  • abbie
  • ben
  • robert
  • resolution
  • relationship
Q7

Why does Abbie struggle to balance motherhood and her relationship with Robert?

Abbie struggles because she wants both a traditional family with Ben and to preserve her cherished friendship with Robert. She feels torn between her new responsibilities as a mother and her desire to maintain the stable connection she has always had with Robert while navigating her evolving relationships.

Foreshadowing: Abbie's dilemma between child responsibilities and her desire for conventional family life is established early.

  • abbie
  • motherhood
  • balance
  • robert
  • ben
  • conflict
Q8

Why does Robert become jealous of Ben?

Robert becomes jealous of Ben because he represents everything Robert cannot be for Abbie - a romantic partner. As Abbie falls in love with Ben, Robert watches his position as her most important person being taken, triggering feelings of loss, loneliness, and insecurity about his role in her life.

Foreshadowing: Robert's feelings of loneliness intensify as Abbie becomes more entwined with Ben.

  • robert
  • ben
  • jealousy
  • romance
  • loss
Q9

What triggers the confrontation between Abbie and Robert?

The confrontation is triggered by mounting tension from Robert's unresolved feelings and his perceived displacement in Abbie's life. As their emotional distances grow, they reach a boiling point where they must finally address the unspoken feelings and fears that have been building throughout the film.

Foreshadowing: The emotional strain manifests in several conflicts before the final confrontation.

  • confrontation
  • feelings
  • emotional tension
  • resolution
Q10

What makes Abbie and Robert's relationship so complicated?

Their relationship is complicated because it exists in an unusual space between friendship, family, and latent romance. They share a child, live in close proximity, and have deep emotional history, yet their romantic feelings remain unspoken for years, creating tension that simple friendship or romance cannot explain.

Foreshadowing: The film introduces their profound friendship as the foundation of a unique situation.

  • friendship
  • romance
  • complexity
  • unrequited feelings
  • co-parenting

Movie threads

More Movies Like The Next Best Thing, by Mood & Story

Curated lists built around what makes The Next Best Thing tick: the same mood, the same kind of story or the same emotional payoff. Each list explains why these movies belong together.

Movies about bittersweet found families like The Next Best Thing

Stories where unconventional families form, bringing joy and complicated heartache. If you liked the unconventional family dynamics in The Next Best Thing, explore more movies about bittersweet found families. These films focus on the joy and complication of building a life and raising children outside of traditional norms, often with a heartfelt and poignant tone.

  • heartfelt
  • bittersweet
  • tender
  • conflicted
  • introspective
  • melancholic
  • Tone: bittersweet, heartfelt
  • Pacing: steady, character-driven
Why these movies?

The story pattern: These narratives typically begin with an unconventional arrangement—friends, co-parents, or a group of outsiders—coming together to form a family unit. The story explores the profound joy and deep connection this brings, but also the inevitable conflicts, jealousies, and societal pressures that test the bonds, leading to a redefinition of what family means.

Why they belong together: Movies in this thread are grouped by their shared focus on the emotional complexity of non-traditional families. They blend heartfelt connections with the pain of navigating expectations, resulting in a consistently bittersweet and introspective mood.

Movies about friendships tested by love like The Next Best Thing

Deep friendships are strained by unexpected romance, life choices, and jealous longing. Looking for more movies like The Next Best Thing where a deep friendship is strained by love and life changes? This collection features stories about lifelong friends confronting jealousy, unrequited feelings, and the complex emotions that arise when their relationship dynamic is irrevocably altered.

  • conflicted
  • introspective
  • awkward
  • melancholic
  • tender
  • heartfelt
  • Tone: bittersweet, conflicted
  • Pacing: steady
Why these movies?

The story pattern: The narrative pattern centers on a profound, long-standing friendship between two people. A pivotal event, often an unexpected romantic encounter or a joint life decision like parenthood, introduces tension and latent romantic feelings. The story arc follows the strain on the friendship as characters grapple with jealousy, changing identities, and the painful process of redefining their connection.

Why they belong together: These movies share a specific emotional journey: the evolution of a platonic friendship under the pressure of romantic complications. They feature a steady, character-driven pace, a medium emotional intensity focused on personal drama, and a tone that is inherently conflicted and bittersweet.

If you liked this

Movies Like The Next Best Thing

Similar movies to The Next Best Thing: the same genre, themes or kind of story. Each one comes with its own plot summary, timeline and ending explained.

Browse all movie summaries

Every angle

The Next Best Thing (2000) Explained: Plot, Timeline & Characters

Everything about The Next Best Thing in one place: what happens in the plot summary, the timeline in chronological order, the characters and meaning and a spoiler-free summary. What's After the Movie adds the cast, box office and post-credit scenes.

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

Plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Catch up on any movie in minutes, save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private, always.

Learn more about the app