Deception 6 steps
How Lisa and Evan Killed Mathew and Meagan and Covered Their Tracks
Lisa shot Matthew in his room while wearing the mascot costume she knew he would wear, then shot Meagan when the woman hid in the wardrobe, while Evan supported the cover-up by sending misleading texts from Matthew's phone and hiding Meagan's body. The diagram lays out how the disguise, the opened window, the fake texts, and the body disposal combined to make the killings appear to be someone else's work.
Read the 6 steps as text
- 1
Lisa shoots Matthew wearing the mascot costume
Lisa · Mathew Danbury
What it looked like: The scene was arranged to make it look as though someone other than Lisa had killed Matthew.
Lisa, knowing Matthew would wear the mascot costume after the reunion, used the same costume to hide her identity and shot Matthew in his room, staging the scene so he appeared to be killed by someone else.
- 2
Lisa opens the window to let in the cold
Lisa
Lisa opened the window to let in the cold air, which delayed detection of the time of death.
- 3
Lisa shoots Meagan in the wardrobe
Lisa · Meagan Cooper
Meagan, trying to reconnect with Matthew, hid in the wardrobe, and Lisa used the opportunity to shoot her, eliminating anyone who might threaten her secret.
- 4
Evan sends lewd texts from Matthew's phone
Evan West · Mathew Danbury
Evan helped Lisa by sending lewd texts from Matthew's phone in order to create confusion.
- 5
Evan hides Meagan's body in the car trunk
Evan West · Meagan Cooper
Evan hid Meagan's body in the trunk of the car, wearing the mascot costume to conceal his identity while moving the bodies.
- 6
Cover-up conceals the killers and secures the inheritance
Lisa · Evan West
What it looked like: The deaths were meant to look like the work of an outside killer rather than Lisa and Evan.
The combined staging made the killings appear to be someone else's work, protecting Lisa's and Evan's secret so that Lisa could inherit Matthew's wealth.
