Richard Grimes and Rachel Biegler are a middle-aged couple who feel the weight of infertility pressing on their life plans. After several failed attempts at artificial insemination, they decide to pursue in vitro fertilization (IVF), hoping medical science can open a doorway to the family they’ve long wanted. A troubling medical setback soon comes into play: Richard carries a blockage that stops him from producing sperm. To address this, he undergoes surgery that leaves the couple $10,000 in debt to his brother, Charlie Grimes, and to his wife, Cynthia Grimes. The financial strain is heavy, but the emotional stakes are heavier still as they navigate the rocky terrain of trying to become parents.
At the same time, the couple pursues adoption and goes through an interview with a social worker, hoping one path might yield a child to love. Their journey toward parenthood is further complicated by a thread from the past: a supposed pregnancy from a teenager in Little Rock, Arkansas. They travel to investigate, only to see the contact abruptly dissolve, leading them to worry they fell victim to an emotional scam. The sting of that disappointment echoes as they move forward, holding onto the belief that a child will eventually find its way into their home.
When IVF finally falters, their doctor raises an option that could dramatically alter their odds: using a donor egg to implant in Rachel, a move that could boost their chances from a slim 4 percent to an encouraging 65 percent. Rachel wrestles with the idea at first, but Richard’s steady encouragement gradually shifts her perspective, and she begins to entertain the possibility of donor assistance as a hopeful route to parenthood.
Into this mix steps a beloved presence: their 25-year-old niece, Sadie Barrett. Sadie leaves her writing program at Bard College to move to New York City and live with them, forming a close bond with the couple that makes the prospect of her egg donation feel both personal and meaningful. Rachel, wary of an unknown donor, confronts the idea with care, then leans into it as she considers fulfilling the dream they’ve nurtured for so long.
Thanksgiving becomes a turning point. Sadie announces during dinner that she will donate her eggs to Richard and Rachel, a decision that stuns her mother, and it tests the boundaries of consent within the family. Richard and Rachel insist they won’t move forward without Cynthia’s explicit consent, yet they press ahead with the donor screening process, hoping that this path could still give them the future they long for.
The donor treatment moves forward with optimism, and Sadie—whose commitment comes from love for her aunt and uncle—begins the medical steps with determination. The egg retrieval is successful, but Sadie becomes ill in the aftermath, and she ultimately moves out of the couple’s apartment. Undeterred, the couple proceeds to the implantation, only to face heartbreak when it fails. The emotional toll is severe: their intimacy and marriage have suffered through the long, arduous process, and the relief of completing the procedure clashes with the reality of disappointment.
Time passes, and life unfolds in quiet, poignant ways. Sometime later, they drop Sadie off at the Yaddo colony, where she will pursue a writer’s residency. She expresses gratitude for their help, though Rachel reveals that Sadie’s path was her own doing—an acknowledgment of the independence that has come to define their relationship. Nine months after the failed implantation, Rachel receives a call from another woman who is considering them as potential adoptive parents. The couple heads to a Virginia restaurant to meet and discuss the possibility, and in a tender, quiet moment, Richard slides his chair beside Rachel to hold her hand, signaling that the search for a family—though arduous—continues to be a shared, steadfast journey.
In the end, the story stays true to the core truth of longing, resilience, and the complex ways people choose to build a family. It moves through disappointment and hope with a steady, patient gaze, offering a nuanced portrait of love, sacrifice, and the uncertain road to parenthood. The emotional terrain is rugged, yet the characters’ devotion and the ties that bind them remain at the heart of their imperfect, hopeful pursuit.
