No Man of God

In 1985, rookie FBI agent Bill Hagmaier is introduced as part of the Behavior Science Unit's investigation into Ted Bundy. Tasked with delving into Bundy's complex psyche, Hagmaier approaches the assignment with both enthusiasm and trepidation due to Bundy's notorious distrust of the FBI.

Hagmaier begins communicating with Bundy through letters, aiming to build a rapport. Bundy starts to open up, sharing his interests while cleverly probing Hagmaier's personal vulnerabilities, setting the stage for their unique relationship.

Hagmaier visits Florida State Prison for a face-to-face meeting with Bundy. During this visit, the conversation shifts to darker themes, such as the influence of pornography on killer behavior, as Bundy manipulates the dialogue to extract intimate details about Hagmaier's life.

During their discussion, Bundy makes a chilling analogy where he compares investigators to fishermen, suggesting that the deeper they probe, the more elusive the truth becomes. This moment reveals Bundy's manipulative nature and foreshadows the complexity of their exchanges.

In 1986, Hagmaier returns to the prison for another meeting with Bundy, where they examine crime scene photographs related to the Green River case. Bundy provides psychological insights into the case, furthering his manipulation and drawing Hagmaier deeper into his world.

By 1987, Hagmaier meets Bundy again, and they engage in a discussion about their children. Bundy's awareness of Hagmaier’s emotional involvement leads him to taunt the agent, inciting reflections on the nature of evil and innocence, challenging Hagmaier's beliefs about Bundy.

As Bundy's execution date in 1989 approaches, tension escalates with protests outside the prison. Bundy insists he must confess his crimes, believing only Hagmaier can facilitate this crucial moment, while media attention intensifies the situation.

Carolyn Lieberman arrives to represent Bundy, asserting her control over the situation while being cautious of Hagmaier's presence. Bundy, however, adamantly demands Hagmaier's involvement during the confessions, creating a tense dynamic.

During interviews with investigators, Bundy admits to an astonishing number of murders, totaling 30. This shocking revelation emphasizes the chilling nature of his character, as the gravity of his crimes weighs heavily on everyone involved.

With his execution looming, Bundy's mental clarity begins to diminish, prompting a last-minute sanity hearing. Hagmaier's testimony becomes crucial as the psychiatric board must decide on Bundy's fitness for execution, showcasing the psychological complexities at play.

On the eve of his execution, Hagmaier and Bundy share a poignant conversation where Bundy recounts the murder of one of his victims. Hagmaier is left reeling from the emotional weight of Bundy’s chilling reminiscences, contrasting life and death.

Throughout their final exchanges, Bundy expresses gratitude for Hagmaier's support while revealing his own suicidal thoughts. This moment creates a stark juxtaposition between Bundy's intense personal struggles and the grim reality of his actions.

As execution day arrives, Hagmaier learns that he will not be present for Bundy's execution, reducing his role to that of a mere observer. Overwhelmed by the emotional turmoil, he seeks solace in a phone call to his son, illustrating the personal toll of the events.

Cheers erupt outside the prison as news of Bundy's execution circulates, encapsulating the mixed feelings surrounding justice. For those involved, the conclusion of Bundy's life does not equate to satisfaction, leaving lingering questions about morality and evil.