Rudy's life is in disarray, as he struggles to balance his relationship with his girlfriend, [Haley](francesca-reale), and the expectations of his Brazilian mother, [Maria](maria-mancuso). When Haley decides to break things off, Maria seizes the chance to introduce Rudy to other women of his heritage, particularly beautiful Brazilians. Rudy, portrayed by [Rudy Mancuso](rudy-mancuso), finds solace in music that seems to resonate in every aspect of his life; from the melodies echoing in the subway to the rhythms of a diner, it's his escape mechanism. However, this passion detracts from his relationship, leaving Haley feeling neglected and unappreciated.
As Rudy approaches graduation, he finds himself focused on his creative pursuits, namely puppetry and music, which Haley labels as distractions. She desires more seriousness from him, especially as they prepare to move in together at university. Their four-year relationship is tested, and after their breakup, Rudy begins to realize the importance of taking life more seriously. In an awkward move, Maria sets him up with [Luana](camila-senna), another Brazilian girl, but Rudy finds her advances overwhelming.
One day, while running an errand for his mother, Rudy encounters [Isabella](camila-mendes) at the fish market, where the spark between them is instant—albeit comically disrupted when a fish unexpectedly smacks him in the face. Isabella’s genuine interest in Rudy's world opens him up to new possibilities, as she encourages him to elevate his puppet shows into a more significant performance.
Conflicted and caught between his past with Haley and the fresh insights from Isabella, Rudy navigates his emotions. His friend [Anwar](jb-smoove) suggests he explore both relationships, leading to a tangled web of feelings. A misadventurous date with Isabella culminates in an accidental injury that ultimately brings them closer, yet Rudy's inability to commit leads to unintended deceit, as he continues to meet both women.
Tension mounts when Rudy is confronted with the prejudices of Haley's family during a dinner, leading him to rethink his choices. When he tries to break up with Haley at a Brazilian restaurant, fate intervenes as Isabella is also present, intensifying the chaos. Rudy's dilemma forces him to confront his desires—he dreams of happiness intertwined with his passions for puppetry and music, and ultimately for Isabella.
In search of redemption, Rudy attempts to express his feelings through a heartfelt song, only for Isabella to challenge him about his intentions. As he formats his thesis into a script titled “Musica,” inspired by his journey, he finally shares a public showcase that captures the essence of his life—a comedic performance blending his experiences with music and puppetry. In a touching conclusion, Rudy's triumphant show leads him back to Isabella, bearing a reminder of their first encounter—a simple takeout bag adorned with a happy face, symbolizing hope and new beginnings.