Andreas, a contemplative widowed pastor, arrives in a quaint Danish suburb where his predecessor's crisis of faith had reached a boiling point—quite literally, after he ended up punching the organist, bringing about their hospitalization. Settling into a local hotel, Andreas crosses paths with Jørgen Mortensen, a compassionate soul grappling with his own struggles of purpose, especially after having to fire his difficult best friend Hal-Finn from the hotel's restaurant.
Meanwhile, Olympia, a baker lost in despair, cares for her physically and emotionally abusive father, whose harsh words have scarred her deeply. Eager to reconnect with her Italian roots and learn more about her mother, she enrolls in a beginner's Italian class, only to face yet another tragedy when the instructor meets an unfortunate end. Returning home to discover her father has also vanished, she is later devastated to learn of her estranged mother's death.
At the funeral, Olympia meets Karen, who shares her sorrow and unveils an astonishing truth: they are long-lost sisters, separated by their parents' divorce. To shield Olympia from additional pain, Karen keeps silent about their mother's troubled history and battle with addiction. As Hal-Finn's temper leads to his dismissal, he decides to take up the role of Italian teacher, and Olympia convinces both Andreas and her sister to participate in the class.
As a romantic relationship blossoms between Karen and Hal-Finn, tensions lurk beneath their budding romance. When Karen overhears Hal-Finn making unkind remarks about their mother, she is heartbroken and ends their relationship. Meanwhile, Jørgen turns to Andreas for guidance on navigating his challenges with impotence and communicating with Giulia, Hal-Finn's friend, prompting him to muster the courage to ask her out for a walk.
When Olympia unexpectedly inherits money from her father, she splurges on a trip to Venice for the Italian class. In this beautiful city, Jørgen proposes to Giulia, who happily accepts; Karen, after some reflection, forgives Hal-Finn following his earnest attempts to rectify his hairstyle; and Andreas reveals his desire to remain in the parish, extending an invitation for Olympia to join him as a chorister, recognizing her remarkable talent despite her history of 43 failed job applications.
