Fear Street Part One: 1994

In 1994, a horrific incident occurs at Shadyside Mall when Heather Watkins, a bookstore employee, is brutally stabbed by her friend Ryan Torres. This shocking act results in the deaths of Heather and several other mall employees before Sheriff Nick Goode intervenes and kills Ryan.

Following the massacre at the mall, Shadyside becomes notorious as the murder capital of the United States. The media sensationalizes the tragedy, overshadowing the town's struggles and deep-seated issues that residents believe are linked to an ancient curse.

Shadyside residents blame their town's history of violence on a curse placed by Sarah Fier, a witch executed for witchcraft in 1666. This dark belief permeates the lives of the town's residents, influencing their actions and outlook on life.

Deena Johnson, skeptical of the curse, struggles with her personal life after breaking up with her girlfriend Sam, who has moved to Sunnyvale. While Deena copes with her heartbreak, her brother Josh dives into the town's chilling history, uncovering its dark past.

Deena and Sam's paths cross again at a vigil in Sunnyvale, held in honor of the mall massacre victims. The event escalates into a brawl between Shadyside and Sunnyvale students, revealing the animosity that exists between the two locales.

After the vigil, Sam's boyfriend Peter aggressively tailgates Deena and her friends while they are on a bus. In a moment of anger, Deena throws a cooler at Peter's car, leading to a frightening crash that leaves Sam having a chilling vision of Sarah Fier.

The following night, Deena and her friends are pursued by an assailant they believe to be Peter. The group soon faces the terror of Skull Mask and realizes that this threat is connected to the mall tragedy involving Ryan, deepening their peril.

A horrifying discovery hits Deena and her friends when they learn that Sam's accident may have disturbed Sarah Fier's grave. This act inadvertently revived notorious killers from Shadyside’s past, bringing forth a terrifying challenge for the group.

Determined to break the curse and save Sam, Deena and her friends devise a plan to properly rebury Sarah Fier's remains. Unfortunately, their efforts attract the attention of the Camp Nightwing Killer, escalating the danger they face.

In a desperate move to save Sam, Deena reluctantly agrees to a plan involving her own sacrifice. Their journey leads them to C. Berman, a survivor of the Camp Nightwing massacre, heightening the urgency of their situation.

As Deena, Sam, Josh, and their friends confront the killers, chaos ensues, resulting in tragedy as Kate and Simon are killed. Their sacrifices weigh heavily on Deena and Sam, as they fight against the looming darkness of Sarah Fier's curse.

In a gripping moment of desperation, Deena revives Sam after suffocating her with consent, using EpiPens and CPR. This act provides a temporary reprieve from the killers, but complications arise as law enforcement connects Sam's friends to criminal activities.

Following the harrowing encounter with the killers, Deena and Sam find solace in each other, publicly affirming their love amidst the chaos. Their bond grows stronger as they face the aftermath of their traumatic experiences together.

Later that evening, Deena receives a chilling call from C. Berman, warning her that escaping the witch’s curse is futile. The situation escalates when Sam becomes possessed, leading to a confrontation that intertwines their fates with the legacy of Sarah Fier.

The film reaches a climactic moment as Deena faces the possessed Sam, struggling with the darkness that has taken hold of her. This gripping encounter forces Deena to confront both her love for Sam and the horror that the curse has unleashed upon them.