Come Back to the 5 & Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean

A central figure whose gender history and paternity revelation redefine the town’s memories. In 1975 she faces the reunion with a mix of secrecy and resilience, while the backstory reveals a youth spent as Joe, cross-dressing, and navigating social judgment. Her admission that she underwent a sex-change years earlier and that she is Mona’s son’s father reframes the community’s view of her.

The younger version of Joanne, shown in flashbacks wearing a dress and navigating the social pressures of a small town. The memory centers on a 1955 high-school dance, an incident with Leicester T, and the town’s reaction as Joe’s gender presentation is scrutinized. This figure lays the groundwork for the later truth about Joanne’s identity.

A former college student who returns to McCarthy, where asthma and the dry heat shape her attachment to the town. She idolizes James Dean and cherishes a dream of appearing in Giant. Her later claim that Joanne fathered her son becomes the linchpin of the reunion’s revelations and a rupture in the group’s past loyalties.

A senior Disciple who both preserves and probes the group’s past. She challenges Mona’s stories with blunt skepticism, while remaining bound to the shared history of the club. Her stance helps drive the uncovering of Joanne’s true identity and the town’s moral ambiguities.

An elder Disciple whose questions-and-doubts anchor the 1975 reunion. She embodies the tension between nostalgia and truth, pressing for clarity about Joanne’s past. Her presence keeps the memory of the Disciples’s earlier days firmly in view as the truth emerges.

One of the Disciples who remembers the group’s early days and sustains a sense of solidarity. She listens to the present revelations while holding onto the long-formed bonds that first brought the circle together.

Owner of the Woolworth’s five-and-dime store and the town’s anchor, she opens the shop for the reunion and silently witnesses the layers of memory unfold. Her day-to-day routine contrasts with the erupting truths about Joanne and Mona’s son.

A 1955 teenager present in the memory, representing the era’s social norms and pressures around gender and identity. This fragment contributes to the mosaic of the town’s past and the way youth experiences shape later revelations.

A 1955 teen figure whose presence adds to the memory of the town’s social scene. Her perspective helps illustrate the gossip-driven atmosphere that has long influenced how the Disciples speak about themselves and each other.

A 1955 teenager who embodies the town’s social pressures and the spectacle surrounding Joanne/Joe. Her memory enriches the narrative’s layering of identity, rumor, and belonging.

A 1955 teen who contributes to the recollection of the town’s early days, emphasizing the policing of gender norms and the social dynamics that shape the characters’ later lives.

A 1955 teenage presence that participates in the town’s social fabric, helping to illuminate the sexual and gender tensions of the era and how they echo into the later reunion.