In Michael Moore's provocative documentary, he engages in discussions with notable figures such as South Park co-creator Matt Stone, musician Marilyn Manson, and then-president of the NRA Charlton Heston to uncover the underlying reasons behind the Columbine massacre and the alarmingly high rate of violent crimes in the United States, particularly those involving firearms.
The film's title derives from a chilling detail regarding Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, the two students behind the tragic Columbine High School shooting on April 20, 1999. It was initially reported that they attended a bowling class early on that fateful day before commencing their attack, but later investigations revealed they were actually absent from school. Nonetheless, Michael Moore cleverly weaves the bowling theme throughout the narrative. For instance, he captures Michigan militia members practicing with bowling pins as targets. When reflecting on former classmates, Moore learns that Harris and Klebold participated in a bowling class instead of traditional physical education classes, and the girls he interviews generally agree that their interest in bowling held little educational value. This opens a critical discussion about whether educational systems address the genuine needs of the youth, or instead, perpetuate an environment of fear.
Furthermore, Moore ventures to Oscoda, Michigan, where he discovers that firearms are alarmingly easy to access in this small town, particularly since Eric Harris spent part of his childhood there while his father was serving in the Air Force. He goes on to compare gun ownership and violence in various countries, ultimately concluding that there is no direct correlation between gun ownership and violence. In his quest to decipher America's obsession with guns, Moore identifies a pervasive culture of fear instigated by governmental practices and media portrayals. He sarcastically proposes the idea that bowling could potentially bear as much blame for the tragic events as Marilyn Manson, or even Bill Clinton, who was overseeing foreign bombing campaigns at the same time.
One striking encounter unfolds when Moore visits a Michigan bank that offers a free hunting rifle to customers who meet specific deposit criteria. In a humorous yet unsettling moment, he asks, "Do you think it's a little dangerous handing out guns at the bank?" After successfully acquiring a gun post-background check, his bewilderment underscores the film's critique of American attitudes toward gun possession.
As the documentary progresses, it includes poignant montages paired with powerful soundtracks. For example, "Happiness Is a Warm Gun" by The Beatles accompanies a chilling sequence depicting various acts of violence and gun ownership in America. Later on, Moore tackles the concept of institutionalized violence through his dialogue with Evan McCollum of Lockheed Martin, effectively linking the local defense industry's presence to the mentality surrounding the Columbine incident, questioning if children connect missile manufacturing with school shootings.
The film also juxtaposes the fear-based gun culture in the United States with a more peaceful environment in Canada, where gun ownership is similarly prevalent yet incidences of gun violence are remarkably lower. Interspersed with poignant interviews, the documentary serves to illustrate how different cultural contexts shape attitudes toward violence.
Towards the climax, Moore's conversation with Charlton Heston stands out as he challenges Heston on the NRA's stance concerning gun violence. Heston's insistence on the right to bear arms and his defense of the NRA leads to a tense and revealing exchange, culminating in Heston asking the filmmaker and his crew to leave his home.
Through a blend of investigative commentary and societal critique, Moore's documentary holds a mirror to America's gun culture, challenging viewers to confront the deep-rooted fears and ideologies that contribute to this ongoing crisis.
