Auntie Lee’s Meat Pies

Fawn lures Bob Evans, a drifter the group has brought home, into the kitchen pantry and decapitates him with a booby trap. Larry helps clean the car to erase any sign of the victim. The brutal execution confirms the farm’s meat-pie operation is real and now deadly.

Larry helps wash Fawn's car to remove evidence of Bob's disappearance. He and the others work to keep Sheriff Koal ignorant of the killings. The cleanup operation marks the start of their ongoing cover-up.

Coral's car breaks down with a flat tire, and Chief Koal offers a ride to the farm. The sheriff's arrival brings an official presence into the women's domain. Coral is escorted inside, drawing Koal deeper into the family’s secrets.

Investigator Harold Ivars arrives in Penance, searching for Bob Evans. His presence signals increased scrutiny that will intersect with the farm’s activities. The townsfolk begin to wonder about the disappearances.

Larry drives Coral's car to the local auto shop and is spotted by Koal, drawing suspicion. Koal questions him after he notices the skeletal hand in the trunk. Larry spends the evening at the police station, facing questions about Bob's fate.

The four punk musicians—John, Craig, Doc, and Phil—are lured to the farm after their tires are shot out. The women usher them into the house and begin a dinner that doubles as a trap for the victims. Tonight, the killings and body disposal will begin in earnest.

Magnolia brings Doc to Baby's room, where Baby sits in a giant crib. Baby kills Doc by biting and tearing him, in keeping with the farm's horrific theatrics. The diners carry on as if nothing has happened.

Sky leads John to the basement near the kitchen and kills him with a meathook. The family moves with practiced brutality as the screams fade. The night swells with more horrific acts.

Fawn seduces Phil during the dinner, then murders him with a meat cleaver, gouging his eyes and slashing his throat. The other sisters observe the brutality as part of their ritual. The farm's appetite for blood continues.

Coral takes Craig upstairs to an ornate snake altar, paints his body, and begins a striptease before impaling him with the statue’s fangs. The grisly death underscores the farm’s occult motifs. The mansion hums with a macabre ritual.

Harold arrives at the farm to question the women and is greeted by Magnolia. He heads to question Fawn, who is swimming, while Coral, Magnolia, and Sky close in on him at the pool and stab him to death. Auntie Lee prays to Satan, presiding over the carnage.

Auntie Lee prays to Satan in the farmhouse chapel, acknowledging the ritual that has fueled their killings. The moment reframes the murders as a dark rite rather than random violence. The family’s bond and beliefs reinforce their resolve to keep the secret.

The next morning Koal returns with Larry to the farm to confront Auntie Lee. He is told that Larry confessed to the murders, not realizing that it is Auntie Lee and her nieces who are the true perpetrators. The lie cements the family’s control over the investigation.

Fawn lures Koal into the kitchen under the pretense of fixing the sink. Auntie Lee turns on the garbage disposal, grinding Koal's hand, then shoots him with his own pistol. The rampage ends as the town's law enforcement is eliminated and the family remains untouched.