After the Hunt

Alma Imhoff, Julia Roberts, a Yale philosophy professor who has just returned from an extended medical leave, hosts a dinner party at her home in September 2019. Her therapist husband, Frederik Mendelssohn, attends alongside Hank Gibson Andrew Garfield, Alma’s colleague and best friend, and Maggie Resnick Ayo Edebiri, her top PhD student who is openly queer. The gathering is intimate in its warmth but tense with the undercurrents of tenure battles and personal histories. Alma and Hank are both up for tenure, a pressure that frames every careful debate and quiet exchange throughout the evening. The conversation lingers around ambition, mentorship, and the lines scholars navigate to protect their careers, as well as the loyalties that bind colleagues to one another.

During the night, Maggie discovers a mysterious envelope tucked away in the bathroom cupboard. Inside are old mementos and a newspaper clipping written in German, which she pockets for later. Frederik privately remarks to Alma that Hank and Maggie seem to be drawn to her influence—perhaps more for what she represents than for any genuine connection. The next day, Maggie is conspicuously absent from Alma’s class, and that night she confides in Alma that Hank sexually assaulted her in her home after she invited him over for a nightcap. Hank denies the allegation, arguing that Maggie invited him and suggesting she is fabricating the story to undermine his career, pointing to a past disagreement over a plagiarism accusation. The tension between loyalty, consent, and professional duty begins to ripple through the campus like a tremor.

Alma’s decisions grow more complicated as she moves to involve the dean, which Maggie views as a betrayal of trust. Maggie and Hank separately ask Alma for her support, while Alma returns home to find the envelope’s newspaper clipping missing, prompting her to burn much of what remained inside. The following day, Hank is fired and storms into Alma’s classroom, accusing her of not standing up for him to protect her own career. The scene escalates as Maggie walks outside, and Alma follows to comfort her, inviting her to dinner that night. The pair share a fragile moment of reconciliation, but the union remains fragile as Maggie mentions to Alma that a reporter has approached her about going public with the allegations. A faculty colleague, Dr. Kim Sayers, who serves as Yale’s university psychiatrist, urges Maggie to speak out while also voicing skepticism about the way students’ problems are handled in their generation.

When Maggie goes public with her accusation in the Yale Daily News, Alma is forced to confront a painful layer of her own past. Maggie reveals that Alma, as a teenager, accused a trusted family friend of rape but later recanted, a disclosure that casts a troubling light on Alma’s current reactions to Maggie’s testimony. Alma accuses Maggie of violating her privacy, and the moment marks a turning point in their relationship. In the hospital, Alma confronts the truth about her teenage experience, and Frederik helps her lay out the long-hidden details. The truth is wrenching: Alma had a sexual encounter with the man when she was 15, and she had later alleged rape against him—an accusation that contributed to his suicide, though Alma insists she never had sex with him and maintains that it was a case of statutory rape. Frederik reminds her that even if she feels hurt by what happened, the sin of what occurred in the past cannot erase the realities of statutory rape. The admission helps explain Alma’s fragile emotional state and her attempts to reconcile guilt with accountability.

In a pivotal late-night moment, Alma forges a prescription for herself with the help of Kim, triggering consequences that pause her tenure bid. As tensions reach a boiling point, Alma confronts Maggie on campus, leveling a barrage of criticisms: Maggie’s work ethic, her mannerisms, her apparent privilege as the child of wealthy Yale donors, and an insinuation that her relationship with her non-binary partner, Alex, is performative. The confrontation leaves Maggie no choice but to respond physically, slapping Alma in a moment of raw anger and hurt.

Seeking solace, Alma retreats to a wharfside vacation apartment where Hank has secretly returned, using borrowed keys he obtained from Alma’s sister’s past visit. The two of them confront their tangled history. Hank acknowledges flirting with students but denies any sexual or romantic transgressions beyond a past affair with Alma, whom he still harbors feelings for. In a tense and tender exchange, they kiss, but Alma resists his advances and ultimately throws him out, insisting on a boundary she cannot cross.

Back on campus, the fallout widens as Rolling Stone publishes an article in which Maggie’s criticisms of Yale’s handling of the case become a public spectacle. Alma collapses in the hospital from stomach ulcers, a physical manifestation of the mounting stress and guilt she carries. While recovering, she reveals the full truth about her teenage experience to Frederik, who recognizes that the past has shaped rather than excused her actions. He helps her face the ambiguity of consent, responsibility, and memory, acknowledging the nuance that statutory rape can implicate even in the absence of ongoing trauma.

The film moves to a quietly hopeful but complicated epilogue set in January 2025. Alma has rebuilt her career and now serves as a dean, publishing an article about her experiences with statutory rape from her teen years. She meets Maggie at a diner for what amounts to a long, honest conversation about what happened, where their lives have taken them, and whether happiness can be reclaimed after such wounds. Hank has transitioned into a different career as a political consultant, thriving financially, while Alma remains with Frederik, though Maggie remains doubtful about Alma’s happiness and questions whether the article was a genuine act of accountability or a cynical gesture born of ambition and damage. The two women exchange a nuanced glance that suggests both resolve and unfinished business, and as Alma pays and leaves, the director Luca Guadagnino yells “cut!” off screen, a final meta nod to the artifice and control behind the cinematic telling of their story.

Last Updated: December 04, 2025 at 15:32