My Foolish Heart

In New York City, 1939, Eloise Winters meets Walt Dreiser at a student party. They begin with light flirtation but soon discover a deeper attraction.

A few days later Walt asks her to go out; he is initially after a good time, but Eloise signals she seeks a permanent relationship. They decide to date seriously.

Despite initial reservations, the couple falls in love and deepens their bond as World War II looms. Their future seems promising despite looming uncertainty.

When World War II begins, Walt is drafted into the United States Army Air Force, facing deployment. Eloise watches him leave with mixed emotions, knowing their lives will change.

Before leaving overseas, Walt asks Eloise to share a final intimate night with him, hoping to secure a future marriage. She hesitates but eventually agrees.

Eloise realizes she is pregnant and decides to keep the pregnancy a secret from Walt, wanting him to marry her for love, not to legitimize a child. This choice sets the stage for the difficult path ahead.

Before a practice mission, Walt writes Eloise a letter expressing a wish to marry her, signaling his intention to formalize their union. The letter hints at his devotion despite the risks.

Shortly after takeoff, Walt dies in a plane crash, devastating Eloise and leaving her to decide what to do with the unborn child. Her world collapses as grief and obligation collide.

To provide stability for her child, Eloise hastily marries Lewis Wengler, who had pursued her before meeting Walt. The marriage is pragmatic rather than romantic.

The marriage also ends Eloise's friendship with Mary Jane, who had loved Lewis for a long time, severing a key support system. The loss deepens Eloise's isolation.

Near the end of the 1940s, Eloise remains in a loveless marriage with Lewis while dealing with her memories and past. She feels the weight of choices that defined her life.

Mary Jane visits Eloise, who is grappling with divorce and custody issues as she reflects on her past and her lost opportunities. Her presence stirs unresolved feelings.

During the confrontation, Eloise admits she wants Lewis and Mary Jane to live together and share custody of their daughter Ramona. The idea reveals a longing for nontraditional family arrangements.

Seeing Eloise's affectionate bond with Ramona, Mary Jane tells her to stay with the child; Lewis and Mary Jane depart, leaving Eloise to stay with Ramona.