Plot Explained Spoilers guaranteed!
Plot Explained

Browse by genre

I Believe in Unicorns (2015) movie poster

Plot Summary

I Believe in Unicorns (2015) Plot Summary Explained

Release, runtime and language
2015 · 80 min · English
Loading streaming availability…
Directed by
Leah Meyerhoff

Davina, a teenager facing difficult circumstances, creates a rich fantasy world to cope with her struggles. Her life takes a hopeful turn when she embarks on a romance with Sterling, an older man who seems to offer a path to her dreams. However, his unpredictable behavior threatens her carefully constructed reality, forcing her to confront painful truths and the complexities of growing up.

On this page (6)
  1. 1 Where to watch
  2. 2 What happens: full plot
  3. 3 Plot questions answered
  4. 4 Movie threads
  5. 5 Movies like I Believe in Unicorns
  6. 6 Every angle
Loading streaming availability…

Full plot summary · contains spoilers

What Happens in I Believe in Unicorns: Full Plot Summary

The whole story of I Believe in Unicorns (2015) explained, from the opening scene to the final frame: every key event, every twist and what it all adds up to. Read it as a quick recap before the sequel, to check a scene you missed, or to finally understand what really happened.

As a high school freshman from Berkeley, Davina finds her life intricately tied to the ongoing struggles of her mother, who battles the unyielding advance of multiple sclerosis. The absence of her father, who left shortly after her birth, has profoundly affected Davina's sense of identity, leaving her feeling adrift. On her 16th birthday, she enjoys a simple celebration with her closest friend, Cassidy (character A), who generously gifts her a camera. It’s during a delightful picnic that Davina's gaze first lands on Sterling, a rebellious punk known for cruising the park's skate ramp with his crew.

As Davina's infatuation with Sterling grows, she begins to immortalize him through her camera lens. Their paths converge, leading to a brief exchange that ends with Sterling inviting her to meet again at a nearby street corner. Taking a leap of faith, Davina agrees, and the two embark on a shared day full of deep conversations, revealing their mutual yearning to break free from their stifling realities.

In their time together, Davina learns about Sterling’s troubled past, including the escape from his abusive father, which opens her eyes to the struggles he endures. The tension of their shared longing for freedom binds them closer, and as night falls, Sterling invites Davina to his humble home in a more challenging part of town. Their chemistry ignites into a passionate moment, marking a significant turning point in their young lives.

The dawn after their encounter brings mixed feelings for Davina. She is filled with the weight of new love and a budding awareness that it may not last. Confiding in Cassidy about her sexual awakening, Davina seeks comfort and understanding from her steadfast friend. Drawn back into Sterling's world, Davina attends a lively rave where she tries to reignite their spark, only to be met with Sterling's rejection, leaving her heartbroken yet resilient.

However, Sterling eventually reaches out with an apology, leading the couple into a chaotic yet passionate relationship. As they contemplate leaving Berkeley together, they embark on a road trip to escape the confines of their lives. The journey, however, proves to be rife with strain as Davina starts to draw parallels between Sterling and his father, igniting fierce arguments.

The climax of their tension surfaces when Davina suggests they head back home, while Sterling insists on continuing their odyssey. Amidst this turmoil of desires and inner demons, they must face the daunting reality that their connection might not withstand the obstacles ahead.

As the night wanes, their space in a motel becomes a delicate haven, challenged by Davina's probing questions about their emotional bond. Sterling's vague responses, matched with his ardent praises of her beauty, leave Davina teetering between intimacy and uncertainty. Their playful moments take a drastic turn when a gentle reprimand from Davina incites Sterling's violence, prompting a stark warning never to challenge him again. The situation escalates tragically, leaving Davina emotionally scarred.

The day after brings them to a serene barn setting, where Davina's wish to leave clashes with Sterling's crumbling emotional state. As she attempts to comfort him, driven by guilt and empathy, their passion ignites for one last time. However, when hesitation creeps in, Sterling's desperate actions shatter their relationship irreparably. The aftermath of that fateful night forces Davina to return home, accompanied by Cassidy, her spirit bruised and battered, mirroring the weary roads they travel.

Last updated: November 17, 2024 at 20:36

Was this helpful?

Plot questions answered

I Believe in Unicorns Plot Explained: Your Questions Answered

The questions people ask most about I Believe in Unicorns (2015): what happens in the confusing scenes, why the characters do what they do, the twists, hidden details and what the ending means. Each answer contains spoilers.

Q1

Why is Davina drawn to Sterling despite knowing so little about him?

Davina is attracted to Sterling because he represents freedom and escape from her difficult reality. Growing up with a mother who has multiple sclerosis and an absent father has left her feeling trapped and invisible. Sterling, a rebellious punk who explicitly expresses his desire to escape their stifling lives, seems to offer her a way out. Additionally, her infatuation is fueled by the thrill of first love and the romanticization of someone who appears to understand her longing for something more.

Foreshadowing: Earlier, Davina and Sterling's first meeting reveals their mutual yearning to break free from their realities, establishing their connection.

  • davina
  • sterling
  • attraction
  • escape
  • freedom
  • first love
Q2

Why does Sterling reject Davina at the rave after she tries to reconnect?

Sterling's rejection at the rave reflects his erratic behavior and emotional instability, which becomes a pattern throughout their relationship. He pulls away when things start to feel real or too intimate, likely due to his traumatic past and fear of vulnerability. This hot-and-cold behavior is consistent with his inability to maintain emotional closeness, setting the stage for the abusive dynamic that emerges later.

Foreshadowing: Sterling's troubled past, including his escape from an abusive father, hints at his difficulty with emotional intimacy.

  • sterling
  • rave
  • rejection
  • emotional distance
  • inconsistency
Q3

Why does Davina forgive Sterling after he rejects her at the rave?

Davina forgives Sterling because she is desperate for connection and escape, and she romanticizes their relationship despite the warning signs. Her emotional vulnerability, stemming from her unstable home life and feelings of abandonment, makes her willing to overlook his hurtful behavior. The promise of the road trip represents hope for a new beginning, and she chooses to focus on that possibility rather than his rejection.

Foreshadowing: Their earlier deep conversations about escaping their realities bind them together in Davina's mind.

  • davina
  • forgiveness
  • road trip
  • hope
  • emotional vulnerability
Q4

What triggers Sterling's violent outburst at the motel?

Sterling's violence at the motel is triggered when Davina questions their emotional bond and challenges him in a moment of vulnerability. When she asks for genuine connection and receives only vague reassurances about her beauty, she gently reprimands him. This act of challenging him, something his abusive father likely did, sets off his violent response, revealing how closely he mirrors his father's behavior when confronted. The incident exposes the abuse pattern that was always lurking beneath his charming exterior.

Foreshadowing: Davina had already begun drawing parallels between Sterling and his abusive father during arguments on the road trip.

  • sterling
  • violence
  • motel
  • abuse
  • trigger
  • father comparison
Q5

Why does Davina compare Sterling to his abusive father?

Davina notices concerning similarities between Sterling and the abusive father he escaped from. During the road trip, his controlling behavior, emotional volatility, and moments of aggression remind her of the father he described. These observations create tension and fuel arguments, as Davina begins to recognize warning signs that Sterling may repeat his father's abusive patterns. This comparison represents her growing awareness of the toxicity in their relationship.

Foreshadowing: Sterling's backstory reveals he escaped from an abusive father, establishing the pattern that Davina later recognizes.

  • sterling
  • abusive father
  • comparison
  • warning signs
  • road trip
Q6

What happens between Davina and Sterling at the barn?

At the barn, Davina tries to comfort Sterling during an emotional breakdown and they share one last passionate moment. However, when Davina hesitates, possibly sensing something is wrong, Sterling's desperation turns to aggression, and their connection shatters irreparably. This final confrontation represents the complete breakdown of the relationship and forces Davina to recognize she must leave. The barn scene marks the point of no return in their toxic romance.

Foreshadowing: The motel violence foreshadows Sterling's inability to control his emotions when challenged.

  • barn
  • final confrontation
  • breakup
  • passion
  • aggression
Q7

Why does Davina finally decide to leave Sterling after everything?

Davina finally leaves Sterling because the barn scene shatters any remaining illusions about their relationship. After experiencing his violence and seeing him spiral out of control, she recognizes that he is genuinely dangerous and cannot change. Her decision is reinforced by her friend Cassidy, who accompanies her home. By this point, Davina has lost her innocence and gained the painful clarity needed to walk away from someone who mirrors the abusive father Sterling himself fled.

Foreshadowing: The motel violence was the first major warning Davina ignored; the barn scene becomes the final, undeniable confirmation.

  • davina leaves
  • final decision
  • cassidy
  • emotional scarring
  • growth
Q8

What is the significance of Cassidy's camera gift to Davina?

The camera Cassidy gives Davina on her 16th birthday serves as a tool for Davina to process her world and capture her fantasies. She uses it to immortalize Sterling, turning him into an idealized object of her escape fantasies. The camera represents her creative spirit and her need to document beauty in her difficult life. However, it also symbolizes how she constructs romanticized narratives, much like the fantasy of Unicorns, that ultimately obscure reality.

Foreshadowing: Davina first spots Sterling while using the camera, establishing its role in fueling her fantasy of him.

  • camera
  • Cassidy
  • gift
  • fantasy
  • documentation
  • symbolism
Q9

How does Davina's home situation influence her relationship choices?

Davina's difficult home life, her mother's battle with multiple sclerosis and her father's abandonment, leaves her emotionally vulnerable and seeking escape. This instability makes her particularly susceptible to Sterling's promises of freedom and a new life. Her longing for a stable, loving figure drives her to pursue an older boyfriend who offers adventure, while her experience of parental neglect may make it harder for her to recognize abusive patterns. Her home situation fundamentally shapes why she stays as long as she does.

Foreshadowing: Davina's 16th birthday celebration contrasts her simple home life with her desire for something more.

  • davina
  • mother
  • multiple sclerosis
  • absent father
  • vulnerability
  • escape
Q10

Why is the movie titled "I Believe in Unicorns" and what does it mean?

The title "I Believe in Unicorns" refers to Davina's need to believe in magical escapes and perfect fantasies, much like unicorns. Throughout the film, she constructs a fantasy world to cope with her difficult reality, her mother's illness, her absent father, and her feeling of being trapped. Sterling becomes her unicorn: a magical escape from her problems. The title reflects her youthful idealism, which the movie ultimately shatters as she learns that romanticized escapes lead to real pain.

Foreshadowing: Davina's creation of a rich fantasy world to cope with her struggles establishes her tendency to believe in magical solutions.

  • title
  • unicorns
  • fantasy
  • escape
  • idealism
  • symbolism
Q11

What role does Cassidy play in Davina's journey throughout the film?

Cassidy serves as Davina's anchor to reality throughout the film. She gives Davina the camera, supports her through her first sexual experience, and ultimately accompanies her home after the relationship ends. While Davina pursues her dangerous romance, Cassidy remains a steady presence who embodies loyalty. Her presence at the end, accompanying Davina home 'bruised and battered', highlights the contrast between genuine friendship and the destructive romance that Davina chose.

Foreshadowing: Cassidy's gift of the camera and her presence at key moments foreshadow her role as Davina's true support system.

  • cassidy
  • friendship
  • support
  • loyalty
  • anchor
Q12

How does Sterling's past with his abusive father affect his behavior?

Sterling's past with his abusive father directly shapes his behavior in the relationship. He escaped his father, but he carries that trauma with him, repeating abusive patterns when triggered. His inability to handle emotional confrontation, his hot-and-cold behavior, and his violent outbursts all mirror the abuse he suffered. Rather than breaking the cycle, Sterling becomes what he fled from, ultimately hurting Davina in ways similar to how his father hurt him.

Foreshadowing: Sterling's revelation about escaping his abusive father early in their relationship establishes the cycle of abuse.

  • sterling
  • abusive father
  • trauma
  • cycle of abuse
  • emotional damage

Movie threads

More Movies Like I Believe in Unicorns, by Mood & Story

Curated lists built around what makes I Believe in Unicorns tick: the same mood, the same kind of story or the same emotional payoff. Each list explains why these movies belong together.

Movies about toxic first love and lost innocence like I Believe in Unicorns

Young love as a destructive force that shatters innocence and forces maturity. If you were affected by the raw portrayal of a volatile first relationship in I Believe in Unicorns, this collection features similar coming-of-age stories. These movies explore the dark side of young romance, where infatuation turns into emotional manipulation, forcing protagonists to confront painful truths about love and themselves.

  • gut-wrenching
  • anxious
  • oppressive
  • coming-of-age
  • raw
  • melancholic
  • Tone: dark, raw, melancholic
  • Pacing: steady, character-driven
Why these movies?

The story pattern: The narrative pattern follows a hopeful but vulnerable protagonist who enters a relationship that initially seems like an escape. The story steadily builds tension as the partner's true, volatile nature emerges, culminating in a crisis that shatters the protagonist's fantasy world and leaves them permanently changed, often with a sad or bittersweet resolution.

Why they belong together: Movies are grouped here for their shared focus on the dark, transformative power of a first toxic relationship. They share a heavy emotional weight, a steady-to-slow pacing that allows psychological tension to build, and a dominant tone that blends dreamlike hope with raw, oppressive reality, ultimately leading to a loss of innocence.

Movies where fantasy meets harsh reality like I Believe in Unicorns

Characters retreat into rich internal worlds to cope with unbearable circumstances. For viewers who appreciated the dreamlike escapism in I Believe in Unicorns, this thread gathers films where characters create elaborate fantasy worlds to survive. These stories often feature a delicate balance between beautiful imagination and a devastatingly real conflict, leading to a poignant and emotionally heavy journey of self-discovery.

  • dreamlike
  • melancholic
  • escapism
  • psychological
  • oppressive
  • gut-wrenching
  • Tone: dreamlike, dark, melancholic
  • Pacing: steady, contemplative
Why these movies?

The story pattern: The narrative follows a protagonist under significant duress who constructs a rich fantasy life—whether through daydreams, idealized relationships, or literal imaginary worlds. The plot steadily progresses as external pressures or the flaws within the fantasy itself cause it to fracture, leading to a climax where reality must be fully acknowledged and endured.

Why they belong together: These films are united by their exploration of escapism as a survival tool and the inevitable, painful return to reality. They share a dreamlike or whimsical aesthetic layered over a dark, serious core. The experience is defined by this tonal juxtaposition, a moderate complexity in portraying internal worlds, and a ultimately heavy emotional impact.

If you liked this

Movies Like I Believe in Unicorns

Similar movies to I Believe in Unicorns: the same genre, themes or kind of story. Each one comes with its own plot summary, timeline and ending explained.

Browse all movie summaries

Every angle

I Believe in Unicorns (2015) Explained: Plot, Timeline & Characters

Everything about I Believe in Unicorns in one place: what happens in the plot summary, the timeline in chronological order, the characters and meaning and a spoiler-free summary. What's After the Movie adds the cast, box office and post-credit scenes.

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

Plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Catch up on any movie in minutes, save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private, always.

Learn more about the app