Heroes for Sale

Thomas Holmes, Richard Barthelmess, and his comrade Roger Winston, Gordon Westcott, are dispatched on a World War I intelligence mission to capture a German soldier. When Roger balks at leaving the shell hole, Tom volunteers to press on alone. He succeeds in capturing a German, but is believed dead in the process; in reality he is wounded and taken to a German hospital to recover. Roger, meanwhile, returns to American lines with the captured prisoner and is celebrated as a hero, the medal he earns framed as a sign of his supposed bravery, while his friend’s fate remains unseen.

Back home, Tom’s ordeal continues in another form. While he is captive, German doctors treat his pain with morphine, and the drugs spark a dangerous addiction. When Tom returns to the United States, Roger tries to help him by offering a job at his father’s bank, but Tom’s addiction has already cost him his post. The truth of his struggle is concealed for a time, and he ends up confined and treated in an asylum. He finally emerges in 1922, unemployed and alone, his mother having died under the weight of his disappearance and the stigma that swirled around him.

Seeking a new start, Tom drifts to Chicago and stumbles upon an apartment above a diner run by Pop Dennis, Charley Grapewin, and his daughter Mary, Aline MacMahon. There, life begins to look up: Tom secures a job in a nearby laundry and forms a budding romance with Ruth Loring, Loretta Young. With his usual energetic drive, Tom quickly outpaces his fellow drivers and earns a promotion, proving once more his capacity to turn a setback into a personal rebound. A new wave of innovation arrives in the form of Max Brinker, Robert Barrat, a radical inventor who creates a machine that would make washing and drying clothes far easier. Tom urges his fellow workers to pool their resources to patent the invention, underscoring his belief that progress should benefit the people who do the heavy lifting on the shop floor.

The laundry company agrees to adopt Brinker’s machine, but Tom negotiates a crucial caveat: no worker must lose their job because of the new technology. The arrangement seems to secure a brighter future—promotion, marriage, and a sense of belonging. Yet fate took a different turn when the company’s president, Mr. Gibson, Grant Mitchell, dies and a new ownership takes control. The new leadership scales back the earlier agreement and proceeds to automate the laundry, displacing many workers, including Tom. A furious, embittered wave of anger sweeps through the plant as employees march to resist the machines’ spread.

Ruth, drawn into the escalating tension, is killed in the turmoil as she searches for Tom, who is arrested and charged as a mob ringleader. The moment becomes a defining turn in Tom’s life: he is sentenced to five years in prison, while the very invention he helped fund continues to roll out across the country, hammering away at the livelihoods of countless others. When Tom is released in 1932, the country has plunged into the Great Depression, and he arrives at a crisis point. Strangely generous in the face of his own fortune, he declines the money he could take from the patent sales, choosing instead to feed the hungry crowds who queue at Pop Dennis and Mary’s diner.

As “Red Riots” ripple through the city, Tom is again targeted by the authorities, and the so-called Red Squad arrests him and forces him to leave town. Homeless once more, he finds himself in a shantytown alongside Roger Winston, his old army ally who has also suffered from betrayal and ruin—his father’s deception, public exposure, and time in prison having left him with little to hope for. The two men, once comrades in arms, confront a bleak future with no clear path forward.

Yet there remains a spark of faith in Tom. In a rousing, unmistakably American speech, he argues that the country can and will rebuild itself—that resilience and unity can outpace even a harsh economy. He marches on, determined to keep faith with the idea that the nation can recover, even as the line at the diner—fed by the money Tom once helped raise—continues to grow and the crowd grows hungry for both food and hope. Back at the diner, a plaque honors Tom for his generosity, a public reminder of his wartime heroism and his stubborn belief in renewal.

The closing image centers on Tom’s son, who gazes at the plaque and declares that, when he grows up, he wants to be just like his dad. The film’s enduring message is clear: a warrior’s courage on the battlefield does not end with the guns; it remains a force for compassion and perseverance in a country wrestling with hardship. Tom’s legacy—built on sacrifice, stubborn optimism, and a willingness to stand up for workers and neighbors—suggests that heroism can persist beyond victory in war, shaping a future where hope competes with despair and community sustains those who stumble along the way.

Last Updated: October 09, 2025 at 11:16