Deception 4 steps
Staging the Prophet's Return from the Dead
Mr. Reed fakes the Prophet's resurrection by presenting her with a blueberry pie he declares poisoned, then replacing the dead woman with a second substitute who performs a memorized script of returning from the dead, allowing Reed to present the event to the sisters as a miracle.
Read the 4 steps as text
- 1
Poisoned pie kills the first Prophet
Mr. Reed · The Prophet
The Prophet enters the dungeon carrying a disheveled blueberry pie, and Reed chillingly declares that the pie has been poisoned and that she will soon be resurrected; the initial Prophet truly perishes.
- 2
Substitute memorizes a script
Mr. Reed · The Substitute Woman
A second woman, acting as a substitute following Reed's orders, memorizes a script to recite for the staged event.
- 3
Substitute performs the return from the dead
The Substitute Woman · Sister Barnes · Sister Paxton
What it looked like: The Prophet herself returns from the dead as a genuine miracle.
The substitute appears before the sisters as the Prophet seemingly returning from the dead, ominously muttering about the afterlife from her memorized script.
- 4
Reed presents the staged return as a miracle
Mr. Reed · Sister Barnes · Sister Paxton
What it looked like: A real resurrection has occurred and can be repeated on one of the sisters.
Reed descends into the dungeon boasting about the miracle and offers to sacrifice one of the sisters only to resurrect her afterward, using the staged return as his demonstration.
