The story unfolds with Noah (Joel Kim Booster), a young gay man, who wakes up after a fleeting one-night stand. He finds himself bombarded with missed texts and calls from his close-knit group of friends, who are gearing up for their annual summer getaway to Fire Island, a vibrant destination off Long Island, New York. Joining his "sisters"—Keegan (Tomas Matos), Luke (Matt Rogers), Max (Torian Miller), and Howie (Bowen Yang)—Noah sets sail to the island to reconnect and unwind.
Upon arrival, they reunite with their nurturing matriarch, Erin (Margaret Cho), whose home serves as their sanctuary. After settling in, Noah and Howie share drinks and reminiscence about their lives, particularly Howie's new job in New York City that distanced him from his friends. Driven by their desire for fun and romance, they jokingly dub Fire Island as the "Gay Disneyland." However, calamity strikes when Max accidentally knocks Noah's phone into the pool. After the phone undergoes a makeshift drying process, Erin reveals her dire financial straits, declaring this might be their last summer at the beloved getaway, igniting a determination among the group to make unforgettable memories while they can.
The night culminates in a lively outing where Noah catches the eye of a charming lawyer named Will (Conrad Ricamora), while Howie finds an unexpected connection with Charlie (James Scully). A misunderstanding kicks off when Noah inadvertently insults Will, mistaking him for another suitor, as sparks fly during a party hosted by Charlie, whose fancy abode starkly contrasts the group’s carefree vibe. Amid awkward encounters and drunken antics, tensions simmer, leading to a chaotic but hilarious series of events that keep the group at the center of attention, even as they clash with the more affluent party-goers.
The following day, after a night of heavy partying, Noah discovers Howie sleeping off a bender at Charlie and Will's place. An ill-timed invitation leads to various misunderstandings, especially when Will warns Noah about not trusting the charming Dex (Zane Phillips), who seems to thrive on social media fame at the expense of others. As romantic entanglements unfold, the group's dynamics shift with Noah and Dex almost sharing a moment, only to be interrupted by more drama.
As complications arise during a dinner party, where Noah and Will's banter turns confrontational, the group navigates the difficulties of friendship, love, and the evolving relationships between them amid wild parties and emotional confrontations. A climatic final stand-off occurs when a video scandal threatens to disrupt their trip, forcing Noah to team up with Will to protect their friend Luke through Will's legal prowess.
As the summer adventure takes unexpected turns marked by loss, confusion, and joyful reunions, Noah and his friends find themselves pushed to their limits, culminating in heartfelt confessions and reconciliations. In the end, the four friends watch the sunset together, embracing love in all its forms, as Noah and Will finally share a heartfelt kiss, surrounded by support from their friends. The journey culminates not just as a vacation, but a transformative summer that solidifies their bond and leaves them reflecting on their choices and new beginnings.
