Plot Explained Spoilers guaranteed!
Plot Explained

Browse by genre

Buffaloed (2019) movie poster

Timeline

Buffaloed (2019) Timeline Explained – Every Event in Order

Release, runtime and language
2019 · 95 mins · English
Echo score 60
JustWatch #1,117 31
Directed by
Tanya Wexler
Starring
Jai Courtney, Zoey Deutch, Jermaine Fowler, Judy Greer, Raymond Ablack, Barbara Gordon

You can’t always take what you want Set in the underworld of debt-collecting, homegrown hustler Peg Dahl will do anything to escape Buffalo, NY.

On this page (6)
  1. 1 Where to watch
  2. 2 Events in order (15)
  3. 3 Timeline questions answered
  4. 4 Movie threads
  5. 5 Movies like Buffaloed
  6. 6 Every angle

Where to watch

Where to Watch Buffaloed (2019)

Where can you watch Buffaloed? Stream, rent or buy it in the US, including on Hoopla, Kanopy and Amazon Video: current JustWatch availability with up-to-date prices.

Streaming availability powered by JustWatch

15 events in order · contains spoilers

Buffaloed Timeline: Events in Chronological Order

Every key event of Buffaloed (2019) in order, scene by scene, with when and where it takes place. Use it to untangle flashbacks, time jumps and parallel storylines, to refresh your memory before the sequel or to find the exact scene you are thinking of.

  1. Peg Dahl is born in Buffalo

    Peg Dahl is born into a poor, blue-collar family in Buffalo. From an early age she witnesses her father's hustling mindset and inherits a curiosity about money. She studies economics in her youth and dreams of Ivy League attendance and Wall Street success.

    When
    birth
    Where
    Buffalo, New York
  2. Childhood ambitions and early hustles

    Throughout her childhood Peg hones a sense for money-making schemes. She pursues economics and builds a plan to finance her education and future. She practices small-scale hustle tactics with the aim of someday reaching the Ivy League and a high-powered career.

    When
    childhood
    Where
    Buffalo, New York
  3. College entry and counterfeit tickets

    Peg earns a spot at a good college but cannot afford it. She begins selling counterfeit Bills game tickets to make ends meet, using her wit to bypass costs. Her scheme is discovered and she is sentenced to forty months in prison.

    When
    college years
    Where
    Buffalo, New York
  4. Prison sentence

    Peg serves forty months in prison for the ticket scam. The experience exposes her to a harsher reality and plants seeds for her later work in reforming debt practices. She reflects on lessons learned while incarcerated.

    When
    prison term
    Where
    Prison
  5. Release and first job at J.J.'s bar

    Upon release, Peg starts cleaning toilets at her brother J.J.'s bar, earning her first honest work after prison. She uses this period to observe local hustles and the debt cycle around her. This grounding experience becomes a springboard for her next ventures.

    When
    post-prison
    Where
    J.J.'s Bar
  6. Entering the debt collection world

    Peg latches onto the debt collection racket, starting from the bottom but quickly rising to the top. She learns the ins and outs of the business, only to be cheated by the firm’s owner, Wizz. The betrayal fuels her ambition to build something her own way.

    When
    early post-prison period
    Where
    Buffalo
  7. Graham at the bar: a key connection

    At the bar Peg meets Graham, an investigator for the DA looking into shady debt collection practices. They connect and sleep together after a bar brawl, sharing information that foreshadows a new venture. This relationship becomes pivotal for her future plans.

    When
    bar encounter
    Where
    Peg's bar / local Buffalo bar
  8. Peg starts her own debt collection firm

    Inspired by Graham’s intel, Peg decides to start a legitimate debt collection business that aims to free people from overwhelming debt. She recruits a diverse crew of hustlers, from phone sex operators to Asian business owners and a fellow parolee. Her pitch centers on helping people by leveraging information and networks.

    When
    early initiative
    Where
    Buffalo
  9. Growth, sabotage, and personal toll

    Peg’s firm grows quickly but is repeatedly sabotaged by her former employer Wizz. The conflict spills into her personal life, as Wizz seizes her brother's bar and puts pressure on her family. The strain tests her resolve and ethics as a leader.

    When
    growth period
    Where
    Buffalo
  10. Confrontation, gunfire, and arrest

    During a tense dinner with J.J., Peg confronts Wizz about rumors and the conflict escalates. She fires shots into the air to gain leverage, but the police intervene and arrest her for firing a weapon. This moment marks a turning point in her legal jeopardy.

    When
    one dramatic night
    Where
    Wizz's premises and bar
  11. Plea deal and turning informant

    In the interrogation room Peg and her mother face questions about family finances. Peg accepts a plea deal and agrees to work with the police to dismantle other illegal debt collectors. This decision signals a shift toward reform and legitimate work.

    When
    post-arrest
    Where
    Buffalo courthouse
  12. Taping confessions and mass arrests

    Peg unites citywide debt-collection agencies for a sting at J.J.'s bar, getting them on tape confessing their practices. The authorities raid offices and 42 people are arrested for illegal debt collecting. Before being taken back, she burns over 50 thousand debt sheets, symbolically wiping out a massive debt burden.

    When
    sting day
    Where
    J.J.'s Bar, Buffalo
  13. Destruction of evidence and prison again

    For destroying evidence she is sent back to prison, where she uses the time to teach fellow inmates about finance as part of her plea deal. The experience strengthens her resolve to pursue finance with ethical reforms.

    When
    post-sting
    Where
    Prison
  14. Release and fresh start

    Peg is released and returns to family and friends who provide seed money to restart. With their support she plans a new venture and pivots toward addressing hedge funds as her next frontier. The reset marks a hopeful new phase.

    When
    post-prison
    Where
    Buffalo
  15. Pivot to hedge funds

    Armed with experience from debt collection reform, Peg begins focusing on hedge funds. She aims to disrupt predatory practices at the highest levels of finance and to prevent debt cycles from harming communities. The film closes on her renewed determination to remake the debt market.

    When
    future
    Where
    Buffalo / wider finance scene

Last updated: December 13, 2025 at 08:21

Was this helpful?

Timeline questions answered

Buffaloed Timeline Explained: Your Questions Answered

When does it happen, and why in that order? The questions people ask about the chronology of Buffaloed (2019): time jumps, flashbacks, cause and effect between scenes and the correct order of events, each answered with spoilers.

Q1

Why does Peg start selling counterfeit Bills game tickets?

After earning a spot at college, Peg discovers she can't afford the tuition. Rather than giving up on her dream, she turns to selling counterfeit Bills tickets as a quick money-making scheme to cover her costs. This reflects her hustler mindset, finding creative (though illegal) solutions when traditional paths are blocked by poverty.

  • counterfeit tickets
  • college
  • money scheme
  • Bills
Q2

Why does Peg join a debt collection firm after prison?

After serving forty months for the ticket scam, Peg starts working at her brother J.J.'s bar cleaning toilets. She then hustles her way into a local debt-collection operation to wipe out her own legal debt. She quickly rises through the ranks but is cheated by the owner, Wizz, which motivates her to build her own legitimate operation.

  • debt collection
  • prison
  • Wizz
  • J.J.'s bar
Q3

How does meeting Graham change Peg's plans?

At a bar, Peg meets Graham, a DA investigator looking into illegal debt collection. After connecting and sharing a night together, Peg learns insider information about the debt racket from Graham. This intel becomes the foundation for her decision to start her own legitimate debt-collection business aimed at helping people escape predatory debt.

  • Graham
  • DA investigator
  • debt racket
  • intel
Q4

Why does Peg start her own debt collection business?

Armed with Graham's inside information about the corrupt debt collection system, Peg decides to create her own firm. Her pitch to a diverse team, including phone-sex operators and a fellow parolee, is that they can help people escape crushing debt through smart, ethical leverage. She frames it as a legitimate alternative to the predatory practices of Wizz and others.

  • debt collection business
  • legitimate
  • ethical
  • team
Q5

What escalates the conflict between Peg and Wizz?

Wizz sabotages Peg's growing business with relentless harassment, veiled threats, and pressure tactics. The conflict intensifies when Wizz targets her family, assaulting her brother J.J. and causing trouble for her mother. This personal attack on her family pushes Peg toward direct confrontation with Wizz.

  • Wizz
  • sabotage
  • J.J.
  • family
  • confrontation
Q6

Why does Peg fire shots at Wizz's premises?

After Wizz assaults her brother J.J. and harasses her family, Peg drives to Wizz's building and fires shots into the air to lure him outside. A physical confrontation erupts, and when police intervene, she's arrested for the firearm incident. This dramatic act marks a turning point leading to her legal troubles.

  • gunfire
  • Wizz
  • arrest
  • police
  • confrontation
Q7

Why does Peg accept a plea deal to work with police?

After her arrest, Peg is interrogated alongside her mother about her financial crimes. She accepts a plea deal that requires her to cooperate with police. This decision transforms her into an informant tasked with dismantling the city's illegal debt-collection network, aligning her skills with lawful enforcement.

  • plea deal
  • police
  • informant
  • confession
Q8

Why does Peg destroy the debt sheets after the sting?

During the coordinated sting operation at J.J.'s bar, police arrest 42 people for illegal debt collection. Before being taken back to prison, Peg burns over 50,000 debt sheets, an act symbolically representing the elimination of more than a billion dollars in debt. However, destroying evidence lands her back in prison.

  • debt sheets
  • sting
  • evidence
  • billion dollars
  • arrest
Q9

What lands Peg back in prison after the sting?

Although Peg successfully helps police dismantle the illegal debt-collection network and triggers mass arrests, she destroys evidence by burning the debt sheets. This act of destruction, despite its symbolic value, violates the law and results in her returning to prison. While incarcerated, she educates fellow inmates about finance as part of her plea deal.

  • prison
  • evidence
  • destruction
  • finance education
Q10

Why does Peg focus on hedge funds at the end of the movie?

After being released from her second prison stint, Peg returns to supportive family and friends who provide seed money for a new venture. Drawing on her experience fighting predatory debt collectors, she pivots to targeting hedge funds, aiming to use her financial instincts to disrupt predatory practices at an even larger scale and prevent debt cycles from harming more communities.

  • hedge funds
  • finance
  • predatory
  • disruption
  • new venture
Q11

How does Peg's family background shape her decisions?

Growing up in a poor, blue-collar Buffalo family, Peg witnesses her father's hustler mindset and her family's financial struggles. This fuels her relentless drive to escape poverty through money-making schemes, eventually leading her to pursue Ivy League education and Wall Street success. Her brother's bar becomes both a safe haven and a target for her rivals.

  • family
  • Buffalo
  • father
  • hustle
  • poverty
  • J.J.
Q12

Why does Peg reinvest all her commissions back into her business?

Instead of taking profits for herself, Peg pours all her commissions back into expanding her debt-collection company. This strategy allows her business to grow rapidly and reach more people, but it also makes her a more formidable threat to established illegal operations like Wizz's, escalating the conflict.

  • reinvest
  • commissions
  • business growth
  • expansion

Movie threads

More Movies Like Buffaloed, by Mood & Story

Curated lists built around what makes Buffaloed tick: the same mood, the same kind of story or the same emotional payoff. Each list explains why these movies belong together.

Movies with an irreverent underworld hustle like Buffaloed

Fast-paced stories about ambitious outsiders bending the rules to beat the system. If you loved the scrappy, debt-collecting energy of Buffaloed, you'll enjoy these movies. They feature ambitious anti-heroes using clever schemes to navigate unconventional worlds, blending comedy with high-stakes drama. These stories share a similar vibe of defiant characters taking on the system with irreverent charm.

  • energetic
  • defiant
  • satirical
  • unconventional
  • ambitious
  • unapologetic
  • Tone: light, satirical, irreverent
  • Pacing: fast, energetic
Why these movies?

The story pattern: Narratives in this thread are driven by a protagonist's relentless ambition to rise above their circumstances through a series of clever, often illicit, schemes. The journey involves rapid-fire successes and failures, confrontations with rivals, and a constant push against societal structures, all while maintaining a playful, character-driven focus.

Why they belong together: These movies are grouped together because they share a unique mix of a fast pace, a light and satirical tone, and a high-intensity plot centered on a financial or social hustle. The central experience is one of rooting for a charmingly unapologetic underdog as they outsmart a corrupt or rigid system.

Movies about quirky defiance like Buffaloed

Character-driven stories about unconventional people fighting for their dreams with infectious energy. Fans of Buffaloed's Peg Dahl will appreciate these films about fiercely ambitious and unconventional underdogs. They feature characters who use their unique personalities to challenge the status quo, blending themes of female empowerment and class struggle with a quirky, energetic feel. These are stories of unapologetic individuals fighting for a better life.

  • defiant
  • quirky
  • unconventional
  • ambitious
  • energetic
  • endearing
  • Tone: light, hopeful, quirky
  • Pacing: fast, character-driven
Why these movies?

The story pattern: The narrative pattern follows a protagonist whose defining trait is their quirky, defiant personality as their primary tool for overcoming adversity. The conflict is often between their unconventional methods and a rigid, impersonal system. The story arc is linear and character-driven, focusing on personal growth, loyalty, and the cost of ambition.

Why they belong together: These films are connected by a shared core of character-driven energy, where the protagonist's unique worldview is the engine of the plot. They balance medium emotional weight with a light tone, creating stories that are uplifting and humorous even when dealing with serious themes like social mobility and injustice.

If you liked this

Movies Like Buffaloed

Similar movies to Buffaloed: the same genre, themes or kind of story. Each one comes with its own plot summary, timeline and ending explained.

Browse all movie summaries

Every angle

Buffaloed (2019) Explained: Plot, Timeline & Characters

Everything about Buffaloed in one place: what happens in the plot summary, the timeline in chronological order, the characters and meaning and a spoiler-free summary. What's After the Movie adds the cast, box office and post-credit scenes.

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

Plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Catch up on any movie in minutes, save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private, always.

Learn more about the app