Maggie Karyn Dwyer has dropped out of university and is living on her own, crashing on a couch in the back of a bookstore that specializes in LGBT literature. After a phone call from her mother, Lila Wendy Crewson, who is divorcing Maggie’s father following his affair, Maggie’s world is upended: Lila and Maggie’s brother, Paul, have to move in with her, and Maggie scrambles to find a loft sublet before they arrive.
Before the houseguest reunion, Maggie meets Kim Christina Cox, a traveling painter whose free-spirited energy draws Maggie into a tender, quickened romance. When Kim’s campervan is impounded, she moves into Maggie’s loft, and the two begin a life together that Maggie carefully guards from her skeptical family. When Lila and Paul finally show up, Maggie presents Kim as a roommate, trying to protect her secret identity as a lesbian from a family still learning to accept it. That night, Maggie’s brother accidentally overhears Maggie and Kim amid their intimacy, a moment that marks the arc of Maggie’s concealed truth colliding with her family’s expectations.
Frances Ann-Marie MacDonald, the bookstore’s owner, is frustrated by Customs repeatedly seizing her shipments as obscene. Judy, a transgender woman who has feelings for Frances, enters the story and reveals that her estranged father has arranged a condo for her to stay in while she recuperates from gender-confirmation surgery. Judy also meets Lila, and the two form a surprising friendship. Maggie begins to clean up homophobic graffiti outside the shop and accompanies Frances on a complaint run to Customs, though their efforts feel fruitless in a system resistant to their message.
Meanwhile, Maggie’s personal life unfolds in a way that tests the family bonds. Judy confesses her feelings to Frances again in an LGBT nightclub, and Frances responds with caution, asking for more time. Paul, meanwhile, befriends Carla, a bisexual coworker of Maggie’s, and they share a connection that adds another layer to Maggie’s already complicated world.
Back at the loft, Lila discovers sex toys left behind by the sublessor and, in a rare spark of self-assurance, uses them, reigniting her sense of independence. The next morning, she asks Maggie and Kim whether they are in a relationship, leading to a tense argument with Maggie about her future and independence. Kim, frustrated by the tension, moves out with her campervan, meeting Judy again before heading out of town. Maggie’s heartbreak deepens as she watches Kim depart, unsure of what comes next for their fragile bond.
Frances hears a tip that Customs will raid her store that night; Maggie urges her to stand up to the harassment. Lila learns that Judy is transgender when a delivery man accidentally outs her, and the revelation shocks her at first. Yet the moment also clarifies the shared mistreatment they both endure, and a booze-soaked walk through the city becomes a release for both women as they vent their frustrations.
In a bold act ahead of the raid, Maggie poses naked with protest signs in the bookstore window. A group of men who had previously vandalized the place threaten her from the street, but Lila and Judy confront them and drive them away. The moment strains Maggie and Lila’s relationship, but it also becomes a turning point: Lila pleads with her daughter to repair their bond, and in a tense confrontation the men return and throw flares into the building, igniting an exposed gas line in the neighboring business and triggering an explosion that tears through the store. The blast leaves Maggie and Lila relatively unharmed, and the two reconciled themselves as the fire and smoke clear.
Frances arrives and, in a quiet, heartfelt moment, confesses her love to Judy. Kim returns in her campervan after a period of reflection and embraces Maggie, acknowledging the depth of what they shared. The film closes with a montage that reclaims the futures of each character. Lila pursues an unfulfilled dream of singing and performs at a benefit show to help fund the bookstore’s restoration. Judy and Frances choose a life together and marry, while Maggie’s brother moves in with Carla. Maggie and Kim continue to travel between womyn’s festivals, with Maggie finally realizing her long-held dream of writing as she publishes her first novel, titled “Better than Chocolate.”
