Agnes of God

The court found Agnes not guilty by reason of insanity because the psychiatric evaluation revealed she suffered from severe psychological disturbances. Under hypnosis, Agnes recalled being told to meet someone in the barn, experienced what appeared to be a traumatic event, and exhibited stigmata bleeding. Her profound naivety about pregnancy and sex, combined with the traumatic memories she suppressed, led the court to determine she lacked criminal culpability for the infant's death.

Mother Miriam knew about the pregnancy before the infant was discovered. Under a second hypnosis session, Miriam acknowledged she was aware Agnes was pregnant and had placed a wastebasket in Agnes's room. However, she denied any role in the baby's death and maintained she was protecting Agnes by keeping her ignorant about sexual matters.

The identity of the man Agnes met in the barn remains ambiguous. Under hypnosis, Agnes described being told by someone who had seen 'Him' from the bell tower to meet 'Him' in the barn, then experienced what she interpreted as a divine or traumatic encounter. Later, she stated 'He' raped her. The film also reveals she heard singing beneath her window for six nights before a man lay with her on the seventh night, suggesting a possible human trespasser.

Agnes claimed a virgin birth because she had been deliberately kept sheltered and naive by Mother Miriam, who raised her. Agnes displayed remarkably limited understanding of how babies are conceived, believing storks or God brought them. She had no memory of the pregnancy or birth itself, leading her to interpret the event as miraculous rather than the result of a human encounter.

Agnes experienced stigmata twice during the film, first after refusing to eat because she believed she was getting fat, and again during a hypnotic session when she recalled the barn encounter. The stigmata manifested as bleeding from her hand. The film presents this as a physical manifestation of either her religious ecstasy or her psychological trauma, leaving the interpretation open between divine phenonemon and psychosomatic response to repressed memory.

The hidden tunnel connected the convent's workroom to a barn outside the property. An archivist explained that many older convents had such tunnels to allow discreet movement between buildings during harsh Canadian winters. The tunnel provided a secret route that could explain how someone could have entered Agnes's room area without detection, connecting the barn where she may have been assaulted to the main convent building.

The court granted permission for hypnosis because Dr. Livingston needed to determine whether Agnes was competent to stand trial. Agnes claimed no memory of being pregnant or giving birth, and her stated naivety was central to the defense. The court order allowed Livingston to probe Agnes's repressed memories, which eventually revealed she did give birth and that someone else in the convent knew about the pregnancy.

Mother Miriam was Agnes's aunt. This family connection was revealed during Livingston's investigation and explains why Miriam was so fiercely protective of Agnes. Miriam had raised Agnes since childhood and deliberately kept her sheltered and ignorant about sexual matters, creating the circumstances that led to Agnes's confusing pregnancy and subsequent traumatic experience.

Sister Marie-Paul was the oldest nun who befriended Agnes and showed her the secret bell tower. She died before the film's main events. Under hypnosis, Agnes mentioned that on the night Marie-Paul died, she was told by someone to meet 'Him' in the barn, suggesting Marie-Paul may have had knowledge about the pregnancy or the identity of the person who assaulted Agnes.

Agnes burned her bedsheets on January 23 after discovering they were stained, interpreting this as a sin requiring confession. Mother Miriam used this as evidence that Agnes must have understood she was pregnant, since stained sheets could indicate menstruation or pregnancy. This became a key point in establishing whether Agnes truly lacked knowledge of pregnancy or was concealing it.

Mother Miriam kept Agnes sheltered partly to protect her innocence but also because of family trauma. Livingston discovered that Agnes's mother suffered verbal and sexual abuse, and Miriam had taken responsibility for raising Agnes. This protective isolation, however, backfired by leaving Agnes completely unprepared to understand or protect herself from what happened.

Before the judge delivered the verdict, Agnes revealed she heard a voice singing beneath her bedroom window for six consecutive nights. On the seventh night, a man lay on top of her. This final testimony suggests Agnes may have been stalked and raped by a human trespasser rather than experiencing a divine encounter, though the film leaves this interpretation deliberately ambiguous.