Plot Explained Spoilers guaranteed!
Plot Explained

Browse by genre

What We Do Is Secret (2008) movie poster

Plot Summary

What We Do Is Secret (2008) Plot Summary Explained

Release, runtime and language
2008 · 92 min · English
Directed by
Rodger Grossman

The film explores the turbulent story of The Germs, a groundbreaking punk band that emerged from the Los Angeles music scene in the 1970s. It follows their rapid ascent to fame, fueled by raw energy and a rebellious attitude, while also portraying the internal struggles and personal demons that ultimately led to their downfall. The biographical drama captures the intensity of their performances and the complex relationships within the band.

On this page (6)
  1. 1 Where to watch
  2. 2 What happens: full plot
  3. 3 Plot questions answered
  4. 4 Movie threads
  5. 5 Movies like What We Do Is Secret
  6. 6 Every angle

Where to watch

Where to Watch What We Do Is Secret (2008)

Where can you watch What We Do Is Secret? Stream, rent or buy it in the US, including on Amazon Prime Video, Amazon MX Player and Amazon Prime Video Free: current JustWatch availability with up-to-date prices.

Streaming availability powered by JustWatch

Full plot summary · contains spoilers

What Happens in What We Do Is Secret: Full Plot Summary

The whole story of What We Do Is Secret (2008) explained, from the opening scene to the final frame: every key event, every twist and what it all adds up to. Read it as a quick recap before the sequel, to check a scene you missed, or to finally understand what really happened.

As Jan Paul Beahm grapples with a challenging childhood in Los Angeles, he finds refuge in education, evolving into an exceptionally bright student at University High School. His unusual demeanor prompts school officials to present him with a perplexing offer: straight A's on the condition that he does not return. Driven by a profound passion for reading and writing, he proposes to his friend Georg Ruthenberg the formation of a band in December 1975. Inspired by David Bowie's legendary song "Five Years," Jan Paul devises an ambitious five-year plan for their musical journey. With instruments obtained through inventive means, the band begins to take shape, featuring Jan Paul as the vocalist, Georg on guitar, Terri Ryan on bass guitar, and Becky Barton on drums.

The nascent group, which would eventually adopt the name Germs, tentatively steps onto the stage for the first time in April 1977. An unexpected meeting with Claude "Kickboy Face" Bessy from Slash magazine outside the Whisky a Go Go leads them to a spontaneous open mic performance across the street. Unfortunately, their debut is met with a tepid response, marked by their struggles with the instruments and heckling from the crowd. In a bid to combat the negativity, Jan Paul retaliates by launching a flour bomb and covering the microphone in peanut butter, resulting in an early ejection but igniting a spark of excitement within the band.

As they navigate the burgeoning punk rock scene in Los Angeles, Jan Paul adopts the stage name Bobby Pyn, which later transitions into Darby Crash. Tragedy strikes when Becky loses her life, prompting a series of lineup shifts before the group achieves a more stable formation. Enter Chris Ashford, who steps in as their manager, urging them to release their first single, "Forming," which would become one of the pioneering punk rock releases from Los Angeles.

With the Masque as their home ground, the Germs welcome Don Bolles as their new drummer, a pivotal point that sets off a turbulent chapter marked by Darby's deep connection with Rob Henley, their romantic partner. Amid this intricate relational web, Germs creates their iconic blue circle logo and the infamous "Germs burn," a circular cigarette burn symbolism on the wrist, which speaks to their identity. Their fame blossoms at the Masque and soon spreads to larger venues, culminating in a chaotic performance at the Roosevelt Hotel on Halloween 1978. During this chaotic creative period, tensions rise as Rob and Don collide over their desire for Darby’s admiration, all while Darby becomes increasingly ensnared in a web of heroin addiction.

The Germs' rise continues, fueled by appearances on Rodney Bingenheimer's radio show and financial support from Slash for their album "(GI)". But as cracks begin to show beneath the surface, Rob plants doubts in Darby’s mind regarding Don's drumming, compounded by the arrival of a new figure, Amber, who positions herself as Darby's manager. The band’s performances grow more violent, leading to them being banned from most Los Angeles clubs.

As Darby's addiction spirals out of control, brewing tensions within the Germs reach a boiling point. Friction arises when Don ventures into a side project, prompting Penelope Spheeris to feature the group in her documentary "The Decline of Western Civilization". They perform under the alias GI at the Whisky a Go Go in December 1979, but when Don fails to show, Darby reluctantly turns to Rob for drumming support, which proves disastrous and leads to the show's cancellation due to crowd unrest.

Following this fiasco, conflict escalates when Darby learns of Don's liaison with a fan, leading him to abandon the Germs and engage in a romantic affair with Amber in London for several months. Returning to Los Angeles with a striking Adam Ant-inspired look and an exaggerated mohawk, Darby reunites with Pat for his new project, the Darby Crash Band, and stages a "farewell show" for Germs at the Starwood in December 1980.

This farewell concert becomes an emotional and cathartic gathering, as Darby informs the audience that it will be their final performance. In a moment of poignant closure, he subsequently passes away, left in solitude and despair, surrounded by the remnants of his tumultuous existence. Pat receives the heartbreaking news while watching reports of John Lennon's assassination, a grim reflection on the transient nature of fame and life's fleeting moments.

Last updated: November 19, 2024 at 20:27

Was this helpful?

Plot questions answered

What We Do Is Secret Plot Explained: Your Questions Answered

The questions people ask most about What We Do Is Secret (2008): what happens in the confusing scenes, why the characters do what they do, the twists, hidden details and what the ending means. Each answer contains spoilers.

Q1

Why did school officials offer Jan Paul straight A's on the condition he never returned?

School officials recognized Jan Paul as exceptionally bright but found his unusual demeanor difficult to manage. Rather than dealing with his presence, they offered him a deal: maintain perfect grades without actually attending. This reflects the chaotic educational approach toward troubled youth in 1970s Los Angeles and highlights how institutional systems often failed to handle creative or rebellious students, pushing them toward alternative paths like music.

  • jan paul
  • school
  • straight as
  • university high
  • los angeles
Q2

Why did Darby throw a flour bomb and put peanut butter on the microphone during their debut?

After facing harsh heckling and poor audience reception during their first open mic performance, Darby reacted impulsively to the negativity. The flour bomb and peanut butter-coated microphone were acts of rebellion and frustration, a deliberate provocation against the dismissive crowd. Though it got them ejected early, this chaotic response actually ignited a sense of excitement and identity within the band, establishing their reputation for deliberate provocation.

  • flour bomb
  • peanut butter
  • debut
  • heckling
  • whisky a go go
Q3

What caused Darby Crash's heroin addiction?

The film portrays Darby's descent into heroin addiction as progressively entangling him during the band's rise to fame. As the Germs gained notoriety in the LA punk scene, Darby became increasingly ensnared in heroin use. The timeline shows his addiction spiraling out of control while tensions within the band rose, particularly driven by the complex relational dynamics and his growing isolation. His addiction ultimately became inseparable from the band's unraveling.

  • darby crash
  • heroin
  • addiction
  • drugs
  • spiral
Q4

Why did Rob and Don clash in their efforts to win Darby's admiration?

Both Rob Henley (Darby's romantic partner) and Don Bolles (the drummer) competed for Darby's attention and approval. Rob and Don collided directly over their desire for Darby's admiration, creating intense internal band conflict. This love triangleDynamic fueled personal resentments, with Rob later planting doubts in Darby's mind about Don's drumming abilities, further destabilizing the group.

  • rob henley
  • don bolles
  • darby crash
  • conflict
  • jealousy
  • love triangle
Q5

What caused Darby to doubt Don Bolles' drumming?

Rob Henley deliberately planted doubts in Darby's mind regarding Don's drumming skills. This manipulation occurred during a period of escalating tensions, as Rob sought to undermine Don's position in the band. The strategy worked, contributing to the growing rift between band members and eventually leading to Don's exclusion from key performances.

  • don bolles
  • rob henley
  • drumming
  • manipulation
  • doubt
Q6

Why did Darby abandon Germs after learning of Don's encounter with a fan?

Conflict escalated when Darby discovered Don Bolles had a liaison with a fan. This betrayal, perceived as disloyalty to the band and to Darby personally, prompted Darby to abandon the Germs entirely. He left for London to engage in a romantic affair with Amber, remaining there for several months. This departure marked a critical破裂 in the band's already fragile structure.

  • don bolles
  • fan
  • affair
  • london
  • amber
  • germs breakup
Q7

What caused The Germs to get banned from most Los Angeles clubs?

The Germs' performances grew increasingly violent, with chaotic and disruptive shows that clubs could not tolerate. Their notorious behavior, combined with Darby's public instability and the band's escalating reputation for mayhem, led to them being banned from most Los Angeles venues. This forced them to seek increasingly unconventional performance spaces.

  • germs
  • banned
  • clubs
  • los angeles
  • violent performances
Q8

What was the purpose of Darby's farewell show at the Starwood?

In December 1980, Darby Crash staged a "farewell show" for The Germs at the Starwood, announcing to the audience it would be their final performance. This concert served as an emotional, cathartic gathering for dedicated fans. However, it was also a transitional moment, Darby was reuniting with Pat for a new project, the Darby Crash Band, making the farewell less of an ending and more of a strategic reinvention.

  • farewell show
  • starwood
  • darby crash band
  • final performance
  • 1980
Q9

Why did Darby Crash die alone and in solitude?

After the farewell concert, Darby Crash died alone, left in solitude and despair surrounded by the remnants of his tumultuous existence. His death came as a tragic culmination of his heroin addiction and the burnout of living at the extreme edge of punk rock excess. The timing, coinciding with John Lennon's assassination, added tragic resonance, with Pat learning of both tragedies while watching news reports. His solitary death reflected the isolation that had consumed him despite his fame.

  • darby crash
  • death
  • alone
  • solitude
  • john lennon
  • assassination
Q10

Why was Becky's death a turning point for The Germs?

The tragic loss of drummer Becky prompted significant lineup changes within The Germs. This tragedy marked the beginning of the band's turbulent journey, setting them on a path toward instability even as they later achieved fame. Her death created a void that required restructuring and contributed to the group's volatile dynamic.

  • becky
  • drummer
  • death
  • lineup change
  • germs
Q11

Why did Rob's drumming ruin the GI performance at Whisky a Go Go?

When Don Bolles failed to show for their December 1979 performance under the alias GI at the Whisky a Go Go, Darby reluctantly turned to Rob Henley for drumming support. Rob's lack of proficiency as a drummer proved disastrous, leading to crowd unrest and the show's cancellation. This failure highlighted the band's internal dysfunction and further fractured their already strained relationships.

  • rob henley
  • drumming
  • gi
  • whisky a go go
  • cancelled
  • 1979
Q12

What was the significance of the "Germs burn" symbol?

The Germs created an iconic blue circle logo and the infamous "Germs burn", a circular cigarette burn on the wrist. This self-destructive act became a symbol of their identity and extreme punk ethos. The burn mark represented their commitment to pushing boundaries, both musically and in terms of personal risk, becoming a visual signature of the band's dangerous aesthetic.

  • germs burn
  • symbol
  • blue circle
  • cigarette
  • wrist
  • logo

Movie threads

More Movies Like What We Do Is Secret, by Mood & Story

Curated lists built around what makes What We Do Is Secret tick: the same mood, the same kind of story or the same emotional payoff. Each list explains why these movies belong together.

Biographies of tragic artists like in What We Do Is Secret

Intense biographical dramas about creative geniuses destroyed by their own demons. Explore more movies like What We Do Is Secret that delve into the turbulent lives of musicians, painters, and writers. These similar biographical drama stories capture the chaotic rise to fame and the tragic personal downfall driven by addiction and internal conflict.

  • tragic
  • chaotic
  • rebellious
  • raw
  • desperate
  • anxious
  • Tone: dark, tragic
  • Pacing: fast, relentless
Why these movies?

The story pattern: The narrative typically follows a meteoric rise in a specific creative scene, fueled by raw talent and rebellion. This success is paralleled by a descent into personal chaos, often involving substance abuse and fractured relationships, leading inevitably to a bleak or tragic conclusion that questions the cost of genius.

Why they belong together: Movies are grouped here based on their shared focus on the artist's journey as a cautionary tale. They combine high emotional weight with a dark tone, presenting a fast-paced, intense look at how talent can be consumed by the very chaos that fuels it.

Movies with a raw punk vibe like What We Do Is Secret

Films that capture the desperate energy and rebellious spirit of the punk scene. If you liked the raw, chaotic energy of What We Do Is Secret, discover other films with a similar punk rock aesthetic. These movies share a fast pace, rebellious characters, and a dark, tense tone that captures the spirit of subcultures defined by music and defiance.

  • raw
  • rebellious
  • anxious
  • chaotic
  • urgent
  • desperate
  • Tone: dark, rebellious, tense
  • Pacing: fast, urgent
Why these movies?

The story pattern: Stories in this thread are less about a specific plot and more about immersing the viewer in a world of defiance and chaos. They often feature characters navigating subcultures, driven by a desperate need for authenticity and freedom, resulting in a viewing experience that feels immediate, loud, and unpolished.

Why they belong together: These films are connected by a shared mood and aesthetic rooted in punk philosophy. They prioritize raw emotion, fast pacing, and a dark or tense tone that reflects internal and external rebellion, creating a consistently high-intensity, anxious viewing experience.

If you liked this

Movies Like What We Do Is Secret

Similar movies to What We Do Is Secret: the same genre, themes or kind of story. Each one comes with its own plot summary, timeline and ending explained.

Browse all movie summaries

Every angle

What We Do Is Secret (2008) Explained: Plot, Timeline & Characters

Everything about What We Do Is Secret in one place: what happens in the plot summary, the timeline in chronological order, the characters and meaning and a spoiler-free summary. What's After the Movie adds the cast, box office and post-credit scenes.

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

Plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Catch up on any movie in minutes, save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private, always.

Learn more about the app