Too Many Winners

On the eve of a duck-hunting vacation, private detective Michael Shayne and his secretary Phyllis Hamilton are in the office, ready to leave, when a mysterious stranger arrives and offers a bribe to drop a case. Hearing that Shayne is headed out anyway, the visitor abruptly departs, leaving a nagging sense that something bigger is behind the visit. Soon after, the enigmatic Mayme Martin extends an invitation to discuss a valuable bit of information she’s willing to sell, but Shayne declines the deal and resumes packing for his trip.

As they prepare to leave, two odd-thugs, acting on orders from a shadowy boss, ambush Shayne to learn what Martin told him. The exchange ends with a brutal beating and Shayne dumped in a city dump, bloodied but not defeated. The mystery deepens, and Shayne, ever the detective, decides to play a waiting game while he pieces together the threads of these early encounters.

Shayne then enlists his journalist friend Tim Rourke to go the distance on Martin’s information, hoping to uncover something solid. Instead, Tim confronts the police and discovers Martin’s body, murdered in what looks like a carefully staged crime scene. The case widens from a simple bribery scheme to a dark conspiracy stretching across a beloved institution: the Santa Rosita racetrack.

At the racetrack, Albert Payson, its president, hires Shayne to crack a counterfeit-ticket racket that is draining the track’s finances. The legitimate tickets are printed by a trusted company owned by Payson, while the track’s daily designs and code numbers are controlled by its manager, John Hardeman. As the plot thickens, a second lead emerges: Gil Madden, the ambitious owner of the Tribune, has long coveted the contract to print the track tickets. Madden financed the Tribune by acquiring a printing company from a former inmate, the man known by the alias Theodore Ross.

Shayne recognizes Madden as the stranger who offered the bribe, and he refuses to answer questions. Madden’s partner, photographer/engraver Ben Edwards, with his own shadowy past, also resists interrogation. The backstory lands hard: years ago Madden and Edwards were convicted of counterfeiting Irish Sweepstakes tickets and sent to Joliet Penitentiary. Madden served a light sentence and was freed, while Edwards drew a harsher term but managed to escape after two years, starting a new life with a wife and child who know nothing of his old crimes.

Hardeman, uneasy that Edwards might talk, begins blackmailing him to force the counterfeit prints. The tension erupts as Hardeman, fearing Edwards will reveal everything, orders his men to kill him—but before the order can be carried out, Edwards himself arrives and shoots Hardeman. In a brutal turn, he is then shot by Hardeman’s thugs, leaving the audience with a cascade of loyalties and lies.

In the final revelation, one of the remaining gang members identifies Joe as the killer of Mayme Martin and Edwards, and Joe is promptly shot by the other thug as the police close in. Despite the brutal truth, Shayne asks the authorities to spare Edwards’ family from the full fallout, choosing mercy over exposure. With the case resolved and ethics intact, Shayne and Phyllis prepare to embark on their long-awaited vacation, the weight of the truth momentarily eased by their bond and a new sense of quiet justice.

Last Updated: October 09, 2025 at 11:06