Saving Sarah Cain

A compassionate yet ambitious columnist at the Portland Times who must balance career ambitions with a newfound responsibility to Ivy's children. She uses the family's story as material for a breakout column, risking the children's privacy and trust. Over the course of the film, she confronts past hurts and ultimately chooses to stay with the kids and their community to seek true redemption.

Sarah's editor who pushes for a story with strong readership. He sees the Amish family as high-impact material and pressures for a compelling angle, even as it raises ethical questions. His constant focus on ratings tests Sarah's integrity and sparks her moral reflection about the kind of journalist she wants to be.

The youngest Cottrell child, six years old, who quickly adapts to kindergarten and becomes a touchstone for the family's attempt to fit in. Her warmth and resilience contrast with the adults' struggles, highlighting the children’s impact on the adults' decisions.

An elder in the Amish community and Ivy's friend who serves as a bridge between Sarah and the community. She advocates for respect toward outsiders and helps guide negotiations about guardianship and belonging.

The eldest Cottrell child who quickly becomes a standout on the wrestling team, demonstrating energy, determination, and resilience as he navigates life away from his traditional home.

A 16-year-old who serves as a protective, thoughtful presence in the family. She helps manage the transition to city life, reveals Ivy's last wishes, and becomes a key mediator between Sarah and the children.

The six-year-old boy who resists the move at first, bringing a touch of innocence and stubbornness to the family's adjustment. His journey reflects a child's struggle to find security in a new environment.

An older Cottrell girl who begins to draw attention from peers after borrowing Sarah's clothes, illustrating the challenges of adolescence and identity in a setting between two cultures.

Sarah's boyfriend who becomes a supportive partner through her upheaval. He expresses disappointment as events unfold but ultimately reconciles with Sarah, symbolizing personal loyalty and forgiveness.

A rival journalist at the paper who uncovers where the children attend school and mobilizes a TV crew to sensationalize their story, representing the press's competitive edge and ethical temptations.