Oliver Courtney is an arrogant composer who habitually takes credit for songs written by others. At a glittering Christmas party, he quietly presents Bob Sommers' tune, "What Would Shakespeare Have Said?", as if it were his own creation. The moment marks a blunt display of his self-serving vanity, and later that night he thanks Bob Sommers for his loyalty with a contract offer—$50 a week for three years—a proposition Bob refuses, explaining he’d rather have a catboat to visit his uncle at his river hotel, Nobody's Inn. The exchange reveals the uneasy balance of power in Oliver’s world, where profit often trumps gratitude and loyalty is a negotiable currency.
When the original lyric writer dies, Oliver moves quickly to replace him, choosing Cherry Lane as a ghost writer. She is wary at first, unsure about toiling in someone else’s shadow, yet she accepts the challenge. Oliver is pleased with her first lyric, and the collaboration seems to promise a smoother, more efficient way to produce hits. Cherry’s ambitions, however, begin to push beyond the confines of that single assignment. She seeks a calmer setting to focus and refine her craft, and her impatience grows as the pressure to outdo herself mounts.
Unbeknownst to them, Bob and Cherry cross paths repeatedly, each blind to the fact that they are working for the same employer. They share a cool, skeptical distance—Cherry does not think highly of him from their early, fragmentary meetings. To chase a perfect environment for creativity, Cherry travels to Tarrytown and stays at Nobody's Inn, while Bob decides to visit the same place at the same time. The reunion is electric: they quickly become acquainted, discover a shared talent, and even begin to compose their own song together. The spark is undeniable, yet a cloud lingers—neither knows the other’s true employer, and the joy of collaboration is tinged with tension as they test the boundaries of professional propriety and personal attraction.
As the two grow closer, their inability to reveal who they truly work for creates friction. Cherry becomes irritated when Bob performs the very piece she wrote lines for, convinced he has stolen her work or claimed more than his share. The tension pushes Bob to a point of confusion, and he returns to town to resign, while Cherry goes to the office to allege that someone has plagiarized her words. The revelation that they are colleagues—yet oblivious to one another’s real identity—drops like a curtain, and the two finally face the truth: their collaboration is a shared labor, not merely a fortunate coincidence.
Realizing they have worked side by side all along, Bob and Cherry put aside their misunderstandings, choosing to pursue their own paths in music, together. After a string of auditions that prove disappointing, Bob agrees to back a band with Cherry at the center, while Oliver’s circle remains an obstacle in their way. They audition for Mr. Westlake, a powerful industry figure who is more interested in Cherry than in their broader ensemble. She declines his offer to join a nightclub, prioritizing loyalty to the duo’s evolving project over a single, glamorous gig.
Seeing a future for Cherry, Bob gives his consent for her to work with Westlake, while resuming his own role as Oliver’s ghost writer. He pools his savings, raises the modest sum of $200, and helps Cherry prepare to premiere their jointly written song at Nobody's Inn. The new arrangement frustrates Cherry, who longs for more control, but Bob is convinced that the opportunity will prove valuable for their long-term plan. Oliver, sensing their struggle, chooses a more compassionate tack: he publicly abandons the notion that the work is his alone, explaining that the song was born from shared effort, not solitary credit. This act of generosity loosens the tension and allows the couple to look toward a future that holds personal happiness and professional achievement.
In a final, hopeful turn, Bob and Cherry acknowledge their impending union and step into the spotlight together. They perform the song they crafted as partners, not as mere hired hands, and their duet marks a turning point in both their careers and their relationship. The narrative closes on a note of reconciliation and mutual respect: a reminder that artistry can flourish when collaboration is honest, recognition is shared, and love supports creative ambition rather than competing with it.
