His and Her Christmas (2005) Characters, Setting & Themes Explained

The film is set in the San Francisco Bay Area, primarily in San Francisco and Marin County. The story unfolds in two contrasting newspaper worlds: the large corporate-owned San Francisco Sun and the smaller community-driven Marin County Voice. The setting uses foggy coastal streets and bustling city corners to create a distinctly Bay Area atmosphere.

• san francisco
• marin county
• bay area
• newspaper setting
• locations

The movie is set in contemporary modern times, specifically during the autumn and Christmas season. The story begins around November when the sale of the Marin County Voice becomes a catalyst, then unfolds through the holiday period toward Christmas. This creates a current, real-world newsroom atmosphere rather than a historical or period setting.

• modern day
• christmas season
• holiday setting
• contemporary times

The two newspapers are the San Francisco Sun, a large conglomerate-owned publication, and the Marin County Voice, a smaller community-driven paper. The Sun represents corporate media with its high-profile production and expansion goals, while the Voice embodies local journalism focused on community connection. This rivalry forms the central professional conflict driving the plot.

• san francisco sun
• marin county voice
• newspapers
• rivalry
• media conflict

Liz Madison is the feisty advice columnist for the Marin County Voice, played by Dina Meyer. She transforms her column into a Christmas-minded editorial to defend her paper's role in the community. Her bold, witty persona galvanizes the Voice's readership, and her editorial stance triggers the Sun's owners to reconsider their acquisition plans.

• liz madison
• dina meyer
• advice columnist
• marin county voice
• protagonist

Tom Lane is the star columnist for the San Francisco Sun, played by David Sutcliffe. He is ambitious, pursuing career advancement including a potential TV show. He responds to Liz's editorial with practical, sharp arguments, creating a witty back-and-forth. Beneath the professional rivalry, there lies a grudging respect and the possibility of a deeper connection.

• tom lane
• david sutcliffe
• star columnist
• san francisco sun
• antagonist

The love rivalry centers on the evolving relationship between Liz and Tom, which begins as professional antagonism and gradually blurs into mutual attraction. Their competing columns feature Liz's empathetic insight versus Tom's pragmatic bluntness, creating a cycle of challenges and small victories. As their columns clash, readers weigh perspectives on Christmas, community, and journalism's role.

• love rivalry
• romance
• liz and tom
• professional antagonism
• attraction

The media power theme explores the conflict between conglomerate-owned journalism and community-focused publications. It illustrates how ownership and corporate strategy influence newsroom decisions, including layoffs and consolidation. The Sun's expansion push clashes with the Voice's community focus, raising questions about editorial independence and who benefits from the news.

• media power
• corporate journalism
• newspaper acquisition
• editorial independence
• community news

Christmas serves as the thematic backdrop that encourages characters to reflect on generosity, forgiveness, and shared humanity. Liz's holiday editorial and Tom's counterpoint frame how festive values can soften rivalry and bring people together. The season provides a lens for potential reconciliation and collaboration amid competitive tensions, ultimately supporting the romantic arc.

• christmas
• holiday spirit
• seasonal theme
• forgiveness
• community values

Vicki Shaw, played by Paula Devicq, is a friend from Liz's circle who offers practical support and a grounded perspective during the newsroom turmoil. She helps illuminate the social and personal stakes of the competitive rivalry between the two newspapers, adding warmth to the story and providing emotional support to Liz.

• vicki shaw
• paula devicq
• supportive friend
• character role

Anthony Shephard, played by Garry Chalk, is the owner and publisher connected to the San Francisco Sun. He represents the corporate angle behind the newspaper buyout and the pressure to monetize the news operation. His character embodies the business decisions that threaten the Marin County Voice's existence.

• anthony shephard
• garry chalk
• publisher
• corporate owner
• sun media group