Aaron Eagle, a Los Angeles camboy who specializes in financial domination, is offered $50,000 to spend a night with one of his viewers, who answers the rental-house door wearing a balaclava to hide his identity. He sets up a camera and asks a series of increasingly personal questions. As the night unfolds, Aaron opens up with memories of being born in Bedford, Maine and describing a sexual encounter where he fulfilled a couple’s rape fantasy that inspired him to become a professional dominant. He refuses to answer a question about a tattoo above his eye reading "Diablo." After a heated confrontation, Aaron’s client reveals that he knows Aaron’s real name, Alex McConnell; in a moment of anger, Aaron unmasks the client, exposing him as his former middle school English teacher, Hank Grant.
Hank Grant is depicted as a pederast who was arrested for attempting to assault one of his students, James Scott, intending to molest him; after a change of heart, he let the boy go and served seven years in prison. He still lives in Bedford, where he works at a supermarket, and has turned to religion in later life. He claims to have been in love with Aaron, remembering him as a lonely boy who was frequently in detention and who flew to Los Angeles to learn about what had become of him. Hank explains that he traveled to meet his former student and to understand his life’s path.
The encounter moves into explicit territory as Hank begins to perform fellatio on Aaron, but stops himself. Over beers, the two engage in a blunt conversation about the nature of perversion, and Hank shaves Aaron’s body hair, attempting to fulfill a perverted sexual fantasy until Aaron grows uncomfortable and physically stops him. The dialogue deepens as the two of them discuss hard truths and personal histories.
During their exchange, Aaron reveals that his first sexual experience involved being molested by his aunt, while Hank recalls a moment from Aaron’s past at a school talent show and asks him to sing the same song again; Aaron refuses. Hank attributes his own pedophilia to being raped by his grandfather from a very young age, with his mother’s tacit approval, lamenting that his life has been consumed by meaningless sexual urges. Aaron counters by saying he was never molested by his aunt, defends his choice to work in sex labor, and tearfully explains that his "Diablo" tattoo is connected to an ex-boyfriend, Rafael, with whom he no longer speaks.
The two engage in sex again, but Hank is unable to ejaculate, and Aaron ends up masturbating himself to completion. After they cuddle, Hank confesses that he did not truly have a change of heart when he assaulted James and that the boy managed to get away on his own.
Come morning, Hank leaves to return to Maine, giving Aaron the rest of his money along with old yearbook photos of a young Alex and Hank. Aaron showers in the rental property, singing softly to himself as the night’s turmoil settles into a quiet, unsettled memory.
