A Brother’s Love

Sophia Anne-Élisabeth Bossé earns her PhD for a thesis on Antonio Gramsci, but discovers a lack of teaching positions in her field and is saddled with student debt. At 35, she lives rent-free with her brother Karim Patrick Hivon and leads tours at a local art gallery. Pregnant, Sophia seeks an abortion, and she and Karim meet Eloïse Evelyne Brochu, a doctor. Eloïse recognizes Karim as a man she met and slept with when she first moved to Montreal several years ago. Although Karim does not remember Eloïse, they agree to see each other again.

After the abortion, Sophia tells Karim he should date a woman like Eloïse, but is turned off when he says he will see Eloïse herself. Sophia loses her job at the gallery and decides to write a novel. She returns to Karim’s apartment and speaks loudly about how she imagined Karim’s date with Eloïse went, speculating Eloïse is frigid and shallow. Sophia is embarrassed to see Eloïse is in the apartment. Envious and concerned about Karim entering into an increasingly serious relationship, Sophia watches Eloïse as she interacts with Karim.

Eloïse and Karim take Sophia to a dinner, and Eloïse also brings her best friend Jasmin Mani Soleymanlou, a male midwife. Concerned she has been lured into a double date, Sophia is offended when Jasmin says giving birth is the most important event of a woman’s life; Sophia never wants to have children. Jasmin and Sophia share a taxi, and Jasmin asks to see her again, though Sophia is reluctant. Eloïse then joins Karim and Sophia in a dinner with their parents. There, Sophia engages in a heated argument over her family, saying the world is overpopulated (when Eloïse expresses a desire for children) and her eight years of education were for nothing. Sophia storms out and refuses to apologize. She leaves Karim’s apartment for a room at Jasmin’s apartment; she also accepts a job as a French-language tutor for immigrants in the suburbs. Jasmin and Sophia have sex; the next morning, Sophia rushes to her new job and struggles on where to begin.

Sophia visits Eloïse in her office and tearfully apologizes for her behaviour at their last dinner. She confesses she had never seen her brother so happy. Eloïse replies by comparing the sibling relationship to atomic theory; since people are made up of atoms, they inherit their atoms from their parents, and she understands Karim and Sophia share a connection.

Last Updated: October 01, 2025 at 13:06