When We First Met

Noah Ashby attends a memorable Halloween party in 2014 that becomes a significant moment in his life. It is during this party that he meets the enchanting Avery Martin, marking the beginning of an infatuation that will haunt him for years to come.

Three years pass, and Noah's affection for Avery remains unrequited as she becomes engaged to Ethan. This development leaves Noah heartbroken, longing for a relationship that seems increasingly out of reach.

On the night of Ethan and Avery's engagement party, Noah is overwhelmed by nostalgia and memories of the past. After a few too many drinks, he discovers a photo booth that takes him back to a pivotal Halloween night, igniting hope for a second chance.

Noah activates the photo booth and is mysteriously transported back to the Halloween party in 2014. Determined to rewrite his history with Avery, he resolves to change the course of their romance.

Noah takes advantage of his newfound opportunity to pursue Avery. However, his initial advances are met with skepticism, making him realize that winning her heart will not be easy.

After receiving advice from his friend Max, Noah adopts a bolder approach to attract Avery's attention. His efforts begin to bear fruit as he captures her interest, marking a significant shift in their relationship.

Upon returning to the present, Noah confronts the reality of his relationship with Avery. He realizes it lacks emotional depth, and discovers that Avery still harbors feelings for Ethan while he has focused solely on his own desires.

With the help of Carrie, Noah learns that Avery is drawn to stable, dependable partners. Motivated by this insight, he embarks on a journey of self-improvement, aiming to become the man Avery would truly desire.

With a new job at Max's company and an upgraded lifestyle, Noah finds himself engaged to Avery. However, he soon faces the consequences of his previous choices as relationships with friends begin to fray.

As Noah's new life unfolds, he grows increasingly distant from his friend Max and witnesses the heartache faced by Ethan after losing Avery. This reflects the impact of his decisions and the toll it has taken on his relationships.

Through discussions with Carrie, Noah has an epiphany about Avery's true feelings and his place in her life. He understands that their friendship will always hold a deeper significance than romantic intentions.

Noah is sent back to 2014 once more to orchestrate an embrace between Avery and Ethan at the Halloween party. In doing so, he hopes to recreate their engagement and restore his friendship with Max.

As Noah facilitates Avery’s reunion with Ethan, he begins to explore his own feelings for Carrie. Realizing their alignment in values and passions, Noah sees potential for a meaningful relationship with her.

After reigniting Ethan and Avery's romance, Noah faces heartache when he finds out that Carrie has reunited with her ex, Phil. He learns an essential lesson about the need for friendship before pursuing deeper connections.

In a grand finale, Noah reflects on his journeys through time and growth, finally realizing he must build a true friendship with Avery. He takes a chance during their interactions to spark a new romance with Carrie, allowing fate to guide his path.