Too Good to Be True

A widowed, successful author who seeks stability for his son and finds himself drawn to Ellen. His initial fascination gives way to withdrawal as tragedy and deception strain his marriage. He struggles with loyalty, love, and whether to protect his family by leaving Ellen. The events force him to confront what truly matters to him.

Richard's son, a sensitive, physically disabled boy who relies on care and companionship. His accident-related injury frames much of the family dynamics and Ellen's manipulation of trust. Danny's drowning serves as a pivotal, heartbreaking catalyst for the story's tragedy. He embodies innocence amid adult scheming.

A beautiful, calculating woman whose jealousy and hunger for control drive the plot forward. She uses pregnancy to bind Richard and manipulates others to serve her ends. Her escalating schemes culminate in lethal consequences, and she struggles with the consequences of her choices.

Ellen's sister, an artist who becomes entangled with Richard through shared secrets and a growing closeness with Ruth. She is drawn into Ellen's web of manipulation and pays a heavy price when suspicion falls on her during Ellen's downfall. Ruth's integrity and artistry contrast with Ellen's deceit.

Ellen and Ruth's mother, a stabilizing presence who visits and consoles but also witnesses the unraveling of her family. She plays a key role in helping pieces come together, including recognizing conflicting signals around Ellen's behavior. Her observations help reveal the truth that others try to hide.

Richard's attorney and friend who counsels caution and offers protective support. He acts as a voice of reason, trying to deter Richard from pursuing a dangerous fixation. Glen's involvement anchors the legal and familial stakes in the story.

A minor figure within the Harland circle who appears in scenes around the Lake House. Not central to the main conflict, Leif contributes to the social atmosphere of the summer setting.

A trusted physician and friend to Richard who becomes involved in Ellen's pregnancy dilemma. He emphasizes medical ethics when Ellen seeks an abortion, complicating the couple's choices. His professional perspective highlights the boundaries of confidentiality and care.

Ellen's ex-fiancé and the district attorney who represents the legal front of the tragedy. He uses his position to pursue Ruth and to uncover the truth, playing a crucial role in the courtroom resolution. His involvement underscores the collision of love, revenge, and justice.

A member of the extended medical/professional circle who interacts with the family; she contributes to the social dynamics surrounding the drama. Her presence adds another layer to the network of relationships involved in the case.

The judge who presides over Ruth's trial, ensuring the proceedings follow legal procedure and weighing the evidence. The courtroom becomes a focal point for truth and accountability as the community confronts the consequences of the characters' choices.