The Most Hated Woman in America

In Texas, 1995, the home of Madalyn Murray O’Hair (Melissa Leo), the founder of American Atheists, reveals a troubling scene; her son Garth (Michael Chernus) and granddaughter Robin (Juno Temple) are nowhere to be found. Food is strewn everywhere, the door is ajar, and Madalyn’s beloved dogs wander freely, suggesting something ominous has occurred. Their friend, Roy Collier (Brandon Mychal Smith), arrives and, sensing that something is amiss, promptly contacts the authorities.

Meanwhile, as the O’Hairs are held captive in a motel room by David Waters (Josh Lucas), a disgruntled former employee wanting to extort money from them, the narrative shifts. We are transported back to earlier times, beginning with Madalyn’s life in 1955 Baltimore, where she grapples with the challenges of single motherhood while raising her son, Bill. When she announces her pregnancy with another child, her father’s discontent looms heavy over their household.

As we rewind into the 1960s, we witness Madalyn and her sons, Bill and Jon, gain notoriety for their fierce campaign to remove prayer from public schools, asserting its unconstitutionality. Despite garnering significant support, this activism brings forth a torrent of hate mail and death threats. During this tumultuous time, she establishes the American Atheists organization and graces the cover of “Look Magazine,” branded as “The Most Hated Woman in America.”

By 1969, having remarried to Richard, Madalyn faces yet another danger when she’s shot by a protester during a radio interview but survives with only minor injuries. Her prominence continues to soar with appearances on legendary talk shows like The Tonight Show With Johnny Carson and Donahue, where she crosses paths with Bob Harrington (Peter Fonda), an evangelist minister, leading to a series of profitable debates. Amidst all this, Bill struggles with alcoholism, leading to his eventual divorce and leaving his daughter, Robin, in Madalyn’s care. In a shocking twist, Bill finds faith through Alcoholics Anonymous and ultimately distances himself from his mother and her beliefs.

Fast forward to the present, Bill receives distressing news about his missing mother and family, initially dismissing it as just another of Madalyn’s publicity stunts. During the early 90s, her decision to hire David Waters for the role of office manager proves disastrous when his criminal past surfaces, leading to a bitter fallout and threats of revenge. The story takes a dark turn in 1998, with David and his accomplices openly confessing to the murder of Madalyn, their bodies later discovered and laid to rest.

In a poignant moment, after visiting her grave, Roy and Bill reflect on their shared loss. Bill firmly declines to pray, stating, > “that’s what she would have wanted,” illustrating the complex legacy Madalyn left behind.

Last Updated: October 27, 2024 at 22:51