The Good Witch

A mysterious, compassionate newcomer who moves into Grey House, Cassie invites trust with a calm demeanor and herbal cures. She tends to Lori's knee with an herbal poultice and opens Bell, Book, & Candle on Main Street, drawing both curiosity and fear. Her past, including the hint of an alias, gradually reveals a deeper connection to the town.

Police Chief of Middleton who starts as a skeptic of Cassie but grows curious as she proves helpful. He balances concern for his children with the allure of Cassie's kindness, and he ultimately shares an intimate dinner with her. His wife's death three years earlier casts a shadow on his decisions and his ability to trust.

Mayor Tom Tinsdale's wife who leads a vocal campaign against Cassie, collecting signatures to revoke her license. She dismisses Cassie's herbal wares as dark arts, fueling town-wide suspicion. Her vendetta exposes the darker side of small-town politics and gossip.

The town mayor who pressures authorities to scrutinize Cassie and aligns with Martha's push to ‘protect’ Middleton. His actions reveal how political power can fuel fear and prejudice, even in the absence of concrete evidence.

Jake's father-in-law who befriends Cassie and encourages new experiences, including visiting his ancestral homeland of Ireland. He becomes a voice of experience and a catalyst for Cassie's deeper ties to the town.

Jake and Lori's son who grows from a surly teenager to a willing ally, especially after Cassie helps him see the troubles in Kyle's life. He asks Cassie for help with Kyle and attempts to bridge divides.

Brandon's sister who battles nightmares and finds comfort in Cassie's dream-crafting, including a dreamcatcher that shifts her nighttime fears toward gentler dreams. Her belief in Cassie grows as the town debates her.

Brandon's classmate who likes to threaten Brandon for lunch money and whose home life is unstable. His actions underscore the town's fragile social fabric and how empathy toward troubled youths can matter in moments of danger.

A neighbor who buys Cassie's aphrodisiac essential oil and later experiences infertility, only to conceive after Cassie's help. Her case illustrates the practical, hopeful side of Cassie's craft and the town's willingness to consider unconventional remedies.

A homeless alcoholic hired by Cassie to assist in renovations at Grey House, a move that stirs controversy among townspeople and underscores the stigma surrounding outsiders. His presence highlights Cassie's efforts to include marginalized individuals.