Plot Explained Spoilers guaranteed!
Plot Explained

Browse by genre

If I Had My Way (1940) movie poster

Timeline

If I Had My Way (1940) Timeline Explained – Every Event in Order

Release, runtime and language
1940 · 94 mins · English
Directed by
David Butler
Starring
Verna Felton, Charles Winninger, Bing Crosby, Moroni Olsen, Claire Dodd, Donald Woods

Gloria Jean, fresh from her breakout in “The Under‑pup,” shines beside Bing Crosby. When worker Buzz Blackwell becomes guardian of 12‑year‑old Pat Johnson after her father’s death, he and Axel Swensen head to New York to find Pat’s uncle. The trio inherit a rundown restaurant, launching a comedy of romance and music.

On this page (5)
  1. 1 Events in order (12)
  2. 2 Timeline questions answered
  3. 3 Movie threads
  4. 4 Movies like If I Had My Way
  5. 5 Every angle

12 events in order · contains spoilers

If I Had My Way Timeline: Events in Chronological Order

Every key event of If I Had My Way (1940) in order, scene by scene, with when and where it takes place. Use it to untangle flashbacks, time jumps and parallel storylines, to refresh your memory before the sequel or to find the exact scene you are thinking of.

  1. Tragedy at the Golden Gate

    Fred Johnson dies in a tragic construction accident on the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco. Buzz Blackwell and Axel Swenson, newly widowed by the loss, vow to locate Fred's relatives in New York City who Pat has never met and to look after the girl. This vow kicks off Pat's journey from her immediate loss toward unknown family ties.

    Where
    Golden Gate Bridge construction site, San Francisco
  2. Telegram to Jarvis

    Buzz informs Fred's brother Jarvis Johnson of Fred's death and Pat's impending arrival. Jarvis refuses to participate in raising Pat, denies knowledge of the telegram, and pretends to be someone else to avoid involvement, directing Buzz to the 'other J. B. Johnson' across town.

    Where
    San Francisco
  3. Directed to the other J. B. Johnson

    Jarvis's deception leads Buzz and the group to the other J. B. Johnson across town, setting up a new search within the Johnson clan. The misdirection reveals the depth of Jarvis's reluctance to engage with Pat's future.

    Where
    San Francisco
  4. Pat welcomed by Joe and Marian

    In New York City, Joe Johnson (Jarvis's uncle) and his wife Marian, a pair of poor ex-vaudevillians, welcome Pat with open arms. They agree to take Pat in and become her guardians, offering warmth and a sense of family.

    Where
    New York City
  5. Axel's financial misstep

    Buzz learns that Axel has used the money saved for Pat to buy a Swedish restaurant that soon proves to be a failure. The financial safety net for Pat is gone, complicating the plan to secure her future.

    Where
    New York City
  6. The money disappears

    Buzz considers handing the Pat fund to Joe, but discovers the funds have already been spent on the restaurant. The group must navigate the new reality where Pat's inheritance is no longer in hand.

    Where
    New York City
  7. Stock certificates as bait

    Buzz allows Jarvis to believe that Pat's stock certificates are valuable, and Jarvis greedily pays $5,000 for what he thinks is a solid asset. The exchange deepens the financial ruse surrounding Pat's supposed wealth.

    Where
    New York City
  8. A nightclub rises from failure

    With the new funds, Buzz converts the Swedish restaurant into a vaudeville-themed nightclub, turning a failed venture into a fresh, lively business that echoes Pat's late father's vaudevillian roots. The club's potential begins to reframe Pat's future.

    Where
    New York City
  9. Jarvis reclaims his money

    Jarvis returns to demand the $5,000 back, hoping to reclaim his investment. The nightclub's success complicates his position, shifting the power dynamics within the family and the financial dispute.

    Where
    New York City
  10. A banker steps in

    Pat's banker friend intervenes, negotiating a settlement with Jarvis to resolve the financial quarrel. The intervention helps ease tensions and moves toward a peaceful resolution within the Johnson family.

    Where
    New York City
  11. Family feud begins to heal

    With the money dispute settled and the nightclub thriving, the long-standing Johnson family feud begins to ease. Relationships slowly mend as the family reconnects around Pat.

    Where
    New York City
  12. Pat finds a new home and future

    Joe and Marian cement Pat's guardianship in the new life they've built for her in New York City. Buzz and Axel support from the wings as Pat looks toward a hopeful future within a loving family and a growing business.

    Where
    New York City

Last updated: February 24, 2026 at 09:30

Was this helpful?

Timeline questions answered

If I Had My Way Timeline Explained: Your Questions Answered

When does it happen, and why in that order? The questions people ask about the chronology of If I Had My Way (1940): time jumps, flashbacks, cause and effect between scenes and the correct order of events, each answered with spoilers.

Q1

Why does Jarvis Johnson pretend not to recognize the telegram?

Jarvis Johnson refuses to acknowledge the telegram because he and his wife are snobby socialites who want nothing to do with the responsibility of raising Pat after her father's death. He pretends to be someone else entirely and directs Buzz to the other J.B. Johnson across town, hoping to avoid any obligation to his late brother's child.

  • jarvis johnson
  • pat johnson
  • guardianship
  • family responsibility
Q2

Why does Buzz trick Jarvis with fake stock certificates?

Buzz discovers that Axel has already spent all the money saved for Pat on a failed Swedish restaurant. To recover funds for Pat's future, Buzz invents a story about valuable stock certificates left by Pat's father. When Jarvis greedily offers to pay $5,000 for these supposed certificates, Buzz uses the money to transform the failing restaurant into a vaudeville nightclub that can actually generate income for Pat.

  • buzz blackwell
  • stock certificates
  • money
  • swedish restaurant
  • vaudeville nightclub
Q3

Why does Axel spend Pat's money on a Swedish restaurant?

Axel, who is often drunk, uses the funds that Buzz and the other construction workers saved for Pat's future to purchase a Swedish restaurant in New York. The restaurant quickly fails, leaving Buzz with the difficult task of finding another way to secure Pat's inheritance.

  • axel swenson
  • money
  • restaurant
  • failure
Q4

How does the Swedish restaurant become a nightclub?

After Jarvis pays $5,000 for the fake stock certificates, Buzz uses that money to transform the failed Swedish restaurant into a vaudeville-themed nightclub. The vaudeville theme is significant because it connects to Pat's late father Fred, who was a vaudevillian, and the new business eventually thrives with help from Pat's friends.

Foreshadowing: The nightclub echoes Pat's late father's vaudevillian background, creating a meaningful connection to her past.

  • vaudeville nightclub
  • transformation
  • business
  • pat johnson father
Q5

Who does Pat end up living with in New York?

Pat ends up living with Joe Johnson, who is Jarvis's uncle, and his wife Marian. They are poor ex-vaudevillians who welcome Pat with warmth and open arms, agreeing to become her guardians. They provide the loving family home that Buzz had been searching for.

  • pat johnson
  • joe johnson
  • marian
  • guardianship
  • new york
Q6

Why does the banker intervene in the family dispute?

Pat has a banker friend who steps in to help resolve the conflict when Jarvis returns demanding his $5,000 back. The banker negotiates a settlement between Jarvis and the group running the nightclub, helping to ease the tensions and resolve the financial quarrel that has divided the Johnson family.

  • banker
  • settlement
  • jarvis
  • dispute resolution
Q7

What causes the Johnson family feud to heal?

The Johnson family feud begins to heal through a combination of factors: the successful nightclub provides a legitimate business that can support Pat, the banker's intervention resolves the financial dispute with Jarvis, and the presence of Pat herself brings the estranged family branches together. With the money conflict settled, the family can reconnect around their shared connection to Pat.

  • family feud
  • reconciliation
  • johnson family
  • pat
Q8

How does Buzz plan to secure Pat's future?

Buzz makes a vow to his dying friend Fred to find Pat's relatives and ensure she has a family to belong to. After discovering the money for Pat was wasted on a failed restaurant, Buzz cleverly uses Jarvis's greed against him by creating the stock certificate ruse. The resulting nightclub provides Pat with both a stable home through Joe and Marian and a growing business that will support her future.

  • buzz blackwell
  • pat future
  • guardianship
  • vaudeville nightclub
Q9

Why does Jarvis agree to pay $5,000 for the stock certificates?

Jarvis eagerly pays $5,000 because he believes he is acquiring valuable stock certificates left by Pat's deceased father. As a snobby socialite, Jarvis sees this as a profitable investment opportunity rather than an act of charity. His greed blinds him to the fact that Buzz is tricking him, and he only discovers the truth when he returns later demanding his money back.

  • jarvis
  • stock certificates
  • greed
  • money
  • investment
Q10

Why is the vaudeville theme significant for the nightclub?

The vaudeville theme is significant because it connects directly to Pat's late father Fred Johnson, who was a vaudevillian. By creating a vaudeville-themed nightclub, Buzz gives Pat a tangible link to her father's profession and legacy. The theme also fits the setting, as Joe and Marian are ex-vaudevillians themselves, making the nightclub a natural fit for the new family Pat has found.

  • vaudeville
  • pat father
  • legacy
  • theme night

Movie threads

More Movies Like If I Had My Way, by Mood & Story

Curated lists built around what makes If I Had My Way tick: the same mood, the same kind of story or the same emotional payoff. Each list explains why these movies belong together.

Heartsong Comedies like If I Had My Way

Uplifting stories where music brings an unlikely family together. Discover more movies like If I Had My Way, where charming musical numbers and comedic mishaps pave the way for a found family to find success and happiness. If you enjoyed the upbeat, heartwarming vibe of this classic film, you'll love these similar stories.

  • heartwarming
  • musical
  • upbeat
  • comedic
  • sentimental
  • whimsical
  • Tone: light, whimsical, cheerful
  • Pacing: steady, gentle
Why these movies?

The story pattern: The narrative follows a simple, steady arc from a modest beginning or a minor conflict to a harmonious resolution. A central theme is the power of community and music to overcome obstacles, whether financial or social, culminating in a successful public performance or business venture that solidifies the group's bond.

Why they belong together: Movies are grouped here because they share a core combination of lighthearted comedy, prominent musical elements, and the sentimental journey of forming a chosen family. They provide a consistently optimistic, low-stakes viewing experience focused on joy and togetherness.

Gentle Underdog Triumphs like If I Had My Way

Sweet-natured comedies about ordinary people beating the odds. Find more charming underdog stories similar to If I Had My Way. These films share a gentle, steady pace and a focus on characters succeeding against the odds through kindness and community. If you liked watching the inheritance of a rundown business turn into a joyful success, explore these movies.

  • underdog
  • heartwarming
  • optimistic
  • comedic
  • charming
  • feel-good
  • Tone: hopeful, lighthearted
  • Pacing: steady, deliberate
Why these movies?

The story pattern: The plot is straightforward, following a clear obstacle that stands in the way of the characters' happiness or success. There are no grand villains, only manageable setbacks. The resolution is earned not through dramatic confrontation, but through collective effort, simple ingenuity, and a stroke of good fortune, resulting in a sweet, uncomplicated happy ending.

Why they belong together: These films are grouped by their shared focus on low-stakes, character-driven challenges and their overwhelmingly positive, gentle approach. They avoid cynicism and heavy drama, offering a comforting viewing experience where kindness and community are rewarded.

If you liked this

Movies Like If I Had My Way

Similar movies to If I Had My Way: the same genre, themes or kind of story. Each one comes with its own plot summary, timeline and ending explained.

Browse all movie summaries

Every angle

If I Had My Way (1940) Explained: Plot, Timeline & Characters

Everything about If I Had My Way in one place: what happens in the plot summary, the timeline in chronological order, the characters and meaning and a spoiler-free summary. What's After the Movie adds the cast, box office and post-credit scenes.

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

Plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Catch up on any movie in minutes, save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private, always.

Learn more about the app