Elsewhere

Sarah is a top student and athlete who longs to escape Goshen's limitations. She is perceptive, determined, and willing to risk her safety to uncover the truth behind Jillian's disappearance. Her loyalty to Jillian drives the investigation, even as she confronts a town that wants to move on. Her resilience and drive anchor the story as she connects clues and pushes for accountability.

Jillian is a mischief-maker with a rough home life who dreams of getting out of Goshen. Her online searching and bold attempts to find an escape reveal a desperate need for a better future. Her sudden disappearance thrusts Sarah into a dangerous investigation and exposes how little the town cares for missing girls. Her character motivates the drive to uncover the truth.

Jasper is the resident computer expert who secretly harbors feelings for Sarah. He becomes an essential ally in piecing together Jillian's disappearance, using his technical skills to uncover clues. His cautious nature balances Sarah's intensity, and his willingness to put himself at risk demonstrates loyalty. He helps turn scattered clues into a coherent investigation.

Mr. Palomino runs the cafe/candy shop where the teens work, serving as a local figure in the community. He provides a setting for key conversations and hints about the town's routines. His character adds texture to Goshen's everyday life, which contrasts with the darker undercurrents of Jillian's disappearance.

Billy is the party host who oversteps boundaries with Jillian, highlighting the danger lurking in social circles. His actions at the party underscore the predatory behavior that the girls encounter. As Sarah investigates, Billy becomes a potential clue whose involvement complicates the search for Jillian. His presence represents a real-world threat that the teens confront.

Officer Berg is a local lawman whose cooperation with the investigation is tepid. The summary suggests the cops are unhelpful, and Berg exemplifies the bureaucratic obstacles the protagonists face. His actions reflect a larger theme of institutional apathy toward missing teenage girls. His presence adds tension by showing how law enforcement can be slow to react.

Maureen is Sarah's attorney mother who has been largely absent from home. Her character highlights the personal costs of ambition and the strain of balancing career with family. Her limited involvement in Jillian's life reflects the theme of parental disengagement that surrounds the teens. She represents the adult world that the girls navigate with limited support.

Candy is Jillian's mother, described as not caring much about Jillian's disappearance. Her indifference underscores the town's apathetic response to missing teens. This character helps illustrate how personal neglect can intersect with a broader pattern of disappearances in the community.

Darla Tod is a fellow teen who works at the cafe and becomes part of the social circle surrounding Jillian. Her presence adds texture to Goshen's teen community and demonstrates how the web of relationships can both aid and hinder the investigation. She helps show the normalcy of small-town teen life amid the mystery.