Bad for Each Other

Dr. Tom Owen [Charlton Heston] returns home on leave, a surgeon with the discipline of a soldier and the instincts of a caretaker. He comes back to Coalville, Pennsylvania, to discover tragedy and tangled debts waiting for him. The news from the wealthy mine owner Dan Reasonover [Ray Collins] is brutal: Floyd, Tom’s brother and a safety engineer, has been killed in an explosion. The deeper shock is the story behind Floyd’s death—substandard equipment, kickbacks, and a heavy debt load that Floyd shouldered alone. Tom’s instinct is to help, to fix the blame and perhaps mend what his brother broke, but Dan makes it clear that Floyd’s missteps were a personal betrayal that cannot be undone with money alone. Tom’s resolve to repay Floyd’s debts clashes with Dan’s refusal to accept help, setting up a tension that threads through the entire film.

At a bustling party, the family’s social circle pulls Tom toward Helen Curtis [Lizabeth Scott], a twice-divorced socialite with a sharp eye for what money can buy. Helen sees an opening in Tom’s need to restore his brother’s fortunes and sees him as a potential match—one that might secure her own position in the social ladder. She arranges for Tom to meet Dr. Homer Gleeson [Lester Matthews], a veteran physician who runs a Pittsburgh clinic catering to wealthy women with minor ailments—many of which are exaggerated or entirely imaginary. Gleeson explains that his former partner has left to open his own practice and offers Tom a place in the operation, a practical choice for someone seeking to steady debts and secure a future. Tom accepts, even as his mother, Mrs. Mary Owen [Mildred Dunnock], had hoped he would return to Coalville for the sake of genuine local service. Tom admits, if only to himself, that he’s taking the job for the money, a confession that unsettles the family’s expectations of selfless service.

To support him in the new role, Tom hires Joan Lasher [Dianne Foster] as a nurse with a bigger dream: to become a doctor herself. Joan is idealistic, practical, and quietly persuasive, and she sees the ethical edge where Tom’s ambition could slip into cynicism. As Tom’s professional world opens up, Helen’s relationship with him deepens, and a proposal follows. Helen accepts, buoyed by her wealth and the promise of a stable future. But Dan’s warning about Helen’s wealth poisoning her first two marriages lingers in Tom’s mind, a warning that he stubbornly chooses to ignore as he forges ahead with his plans.

Joan’s presence introduces a moral counterweight. She is hopeful that Tom’s clinical gifts might be directed toward those who truly need care rather than the affluent who come for cosmetic or frivolous ailments. When Tom’s former comrade-in-arms, Dr. Jim Crowley [Arthur Franz], returns seeking a place to practice, Tom’s reluctance surfaces. Jim’s eagerness to rejoin the field clashes with Tom’s money-first mindset, and Tom’s half-hearted offer of help leaves Jim frustrated and ready to walk away. Yet, in a moment of quiet candor, Jim coincidentally bumps into Joan, who explains how Tom’s wartime example inspired many to stay in medicine for the right reasons. Jim’s determination to serve the needy rekindles Tom’s sense of purpose, and Tom decides to guide Jim toward Dr. Scobee [Rhys Williams], a physician who cares for the miners and their families in Coalville.

Jim is hired and begins to witness a growing crisis among the mine workers—lung conditions that reflect a lifetime of exposure and danger. He presents Tom with X-ray findings, a medical map of what Coalville’s miners endure. The story takes a sharper turn when Mrs. Roger Nelson [Marjorie Rambeau], Helen’s influential aunt, grows gravely ill and requires urgent surgery. Mrs. Nelson is stubbornly insistent on her own physician, Gleeson, who admits he cannot perform the operation and reveals that the actual surgical work had been handled by his former partner for years. Tom steps in, performing the operation and saving Mrs. Nelson’s life, a choice that earns Gleeson’s uneasy approval but sparks a dispute over credit. Gleeson tries to take the limelight, but Tom steadfastly withholds the justification—yet the choice leaves Joan furious and disillusioned, and she resigns in protest.

The ethical glow around Tom’s character fractures as Gleeson’s greed surfaces. Gleeson, who colludes with Tom over a dangerous surgical fee, splits the proceeds with Tom, a transaction that leaves a sour taste in both of their mouths. Mrs. Nelson eventually learns that Tom was the actual surgeon and questions the morality of this credit-sharing, a moment that darkens Tom’s standing in the eyes of those who trusted him.

Meanwhile, the Coalville community’s need intensifies. A catastrophic mine explosion calls Tom away from his Pittsburgh clinic and into the depths where miners struggle to survive. Tom and Jim work side by side to rescue the trapped and treat the injured, embodying a last, stark test of their craft and of Tom’s commitment to the people who rely on him. Jim’s bravery is severe and tragic; he is fatally injured while saving others, a blow that shatters Tom’s sense of balance but steels his resolve.

The aftermath shifts Tom’s path. He declares that he will quit the Pittsburgh clinic and return to Coalville full time, choosing the life of a local doctor who can truly serve. Helen’s response is telling—she cannot imagine living in Coalville, and the distance between them widens until they part ways. The movie closes on a note of quiet, practical renewal: Tom arrives back at his new Coalville office, only to find Joan Lasher already there, ready to join him in a future where medicine and duty are the compass points guiding their work.

This story pulses with the moral ambiguities of ambition, charity, and the price of doing what one believes is right. It threads Tom’s struggle to balance financial necessity with medical ethics, the lure of wealth, and the call to serve those who cannot afford care, all set against the heartbeat of a mining town that literally lives and dies by the energy and danger of its underground world. The characters—from the steadfast surgeon to the hopeful nurse, from the protective daughter of wealth to the seasoned physician at the heart of Coalville’s medical network—paint a portrait of a community wrestling with what it means to do good when the system itself rewards different kinds of success.

Last Updated: October 09, 2025 at 10:41