Above Us the Waves

Commander Fraser, John Mills, leads a bold but controversial push inside a Royal Navy outpost that is torn between two urgent duties: safeguard distant convoys under threat from German submarines and keep the Tirpitz, a heavily fortified battleship, from tipping the balance of the war. The RN brass, including Admiral Ryder, James Robertson Justice, worry about overcommitting to an unproven weapon while the fleet remains wary of the enemy’s capacity to strike from the sea. Against this skepticism, Fraser believes that a small, highly trained force can change the game by using new, untested methods of attack.

Fraser organizes and trains a dedicated team of British commandos and ratings to master the Mk I Human Torpedo, also known as the Chariots, at a secluded Scottish base. With meticulous drills and careful planning, the unit experiments with precision and stealth, aiming to bypass traditional naval power and strike at Tirpitz where it lies sheltered inside a Norwegian fjord. Early attempts involve attaching dummy limpet mines to the admiral’s own ship, a gambit that shifts the mood in the room from doubt to cautious optimism. The success of this audacious move earns Fraser’s force a hard-won authorization to mount an actual attack on Tirpitz, despite the initial policy against unproven weaponry.

The first mission ends in a stark, sobering lesson. The attempt with the human torpedoes fails, and the men are forced to abandon their craft and make a perilous dash to the Norwegian coast. From there, they navigate to neutral Sweden on foot before being escorted back to Scotland. The failure is a sharp reminder that even ingenuity can be thwarted by sea power and weather, but the team’s resolve only grows stronger.

With the lessons of the first attempt in hand, the plan pivots toward a more extended and technically complex operation. The crews train to operate small X-Craft submarines—X1, X2 and X3—designed to slip under Tirpitz and plant “side-cargoes.” These weapons are packed with two tons of explosive amatol and require a daring, precise approach. The new plan depends on towing the X-crafts over the North Sea by conventional submarines, after which they will be released to penetrate the fjord undetected. The excitement around the project is matched by the danger, as any misstep could spell disaster for the sailors involved.

As the operation unfolds, the teams execute a daring detachment beneath Tirpitz’s hull. Each X-Craft carries a heavy payload, and the mission proceeds despite setbacks: X2 suffers serious damage and cannot surface, yet its crew makes the fateful choice to remain aboard to avoid revealing their presence. Meanwhile, X1 and X3 complete their own dives, successfully planting their mines before the submarines are scuttled to avoid capture. The Germans eventually seize the stranded crews as prisoners of war, a tense reversal that could have ended in tragedy, but the captors show surprising respect for their adversaries.

The Tirpitz is not spared by the explosions. The mines detonate in devastating fashion, dealing severe damage to the battleship and forcing a dramatic response from the German crew. The sound of the blasts echoes through the fjord as the attackers’ fate hangs in the balance. The crew of X2, hearing the explosions, attempts to flee, but their side cargoes flood and the craft catastrophically detonate, destroying X2 and killing its crew. The raid is a brutal reminder of the high stakes and the personal costs of such audacious warfare.

Throughout the mission, the film grounds itself in a tone of sober calculation and quiet courage. The men who undertake these dangerous tasks—led by the disciplined command of John Mills and supported by the broader team including Donald Sinden as Lieutenant Tom Corbett and John Gregson as Lieutenant Alec Duffy—embody a blend of grit, ingenuity, and professional discipline. The portrayal highlights not just the tactical ingenuity of using Chariots and X-Craft but the human element—the camaraderie, the fear, and the stubborn resolve to press forward even when the odds are overwhelming.

In the shadow of the fjord and the roar of distant explosions, the crew’s actions are framed by moments of restraint and respect from their German counterparts. The Tirpitz’s crew, though adversaries, recognize the bravery of their opponents in a rare gesture of courtesy that underscores the humanity present even in war. The captain’s quiet acknowledgement stands in stark contrast to the weaponry unleashed below the hull, a reminder that courage can exist on both sides of conflict.

The narrative never loses sight of the technical details that define the operation—the reflections on timing, seamanship, and the risk of detection, all conveyed with a calm, documentary clarity. The result is a detailed portrait of a daring, fate-driven mission that seeks to shift strategic balance through audacious innovation rather than sheer force. The story lingers on the fraught emotions of the sailors, the tension of every approach, and the costly price of pride and perseverance in war.

“Brave men,” the captain of Tirpitz salutes them, providing blankets and schnapps.

In the end, the balance remains delicate. Tirpitz is damaged, altering the naval calculus of the war, while the cost to the attacking crews is measured in lives and lost craft. The mission demonstrates the peril and promise of human ingenuity in warfare, and it cements a legacy of daring that would be remembered long after the fjords had returned to silence.

Last Updated: October 09, 2025 at 14:05