The Good Catholic

The film opens in a charming rectory that houses three Catholic priests, each with their distinct personalities and way of coping with their lives. The routines of daily life are highlighted, offering a glimpse into how these men balance their spiritual responsibilities with personal challenges.

Young Father Dan struggles with the emotional weight of losing his father nearly a year ago. This lingering heartache influences his actions and interactions, creating a backdrop of deep reflection throughout the film.

In contrast to Father Dan's sadness, Father Ollie brings exuberance to the rectory with his passion for food and basketball. His vibrant personality acts as a source of energy, often lightening the mood among the priests and enriching their everyday interactions.

Father Victor, the eldest of the priests, finds solace in his faith and the routine of preparing for mass. His dedication to this time-honored practice provides him with a profound sense of direction, serving as an anchor for the other priests.

As the story progresses, Father Dan develops a special connection with Jane, a troubled musician who seeks solace in the confessional. Her introspective comments about life and mortality resonate with him, leading to a deep, genuine friendship.

Father Dan and Jane share light-hearted moments, playing 'battleship' within the church's sacred space. These playful interactions reveal Jane's vulnerabilities and deepen their connection on both emotional and spiritual levels.

Jane invites Father Dan to one of her performances at a local coffeehouse, where she shares her artistic ambitions and fears about her future. This event allows her to open up further, providing insight into her character and aspirations.

During their developing friendship, Father Dan confides in Jane about his personal struggles, allowing him to find renewed purpose in his role as a priest. Their conversations help both characters grow, despite the challenges they face.

A significant moment occurs when Father Dan gifts Jane a Bible, which she receives harshly during a lively rectory bingo night. This reaction introduces tension in their relationship and highlights Jane's inner turmoil regarding faith and her future.

Father Dan invites Jane to dinner at the rectory, where the atmosphere becomes charged with emotions. While Ollie enjoys the meal, Victor probes Father Dan about his true passions, leading to a rift when Jane feels overlooked and decides to leave.

In the aftermath of Jane’s departure, Father Victor delivers a poignant homily reflecting on the relationship between love and divinity. This moment prompts Father Dan to reflect deeply on his feelings for Jane and the significance of their bond.

In a moment of emotional clarity, Father Dan races to Jane's home to reconcile. By removing his clerical collar before knocking on her door, he signifies an important shift in their relationship and a willingness to confront the complexities of love and priesthood.

The film culminates in this pivotal moment of connection between Father Dan and Jane, where they are faced with the challenges of their evolving relationship. This signifies a new chapter not only for them but also encapsulates the film's exploration of faith, love, and human connection.