Superman vs. The Elite

The Man of Steel anchors the story with a steadfast moral compass, prioritizing civilian safety over vengeance. He rescues those trapped on a submerged subway and consistently argues for non-lethal methods, even as he faces aggressive tactics from The Elite. His stance illuminates the film’s core message: power must serve the vulnerable and be exercised with restraint and accountability.

The Elite’s strategist and public face, Manchester Black champions swift, lethal action to achieve perceived peace. He uses charisma and power to frame his methods as necessary, prompting moral questions about leadership, authority, and the boundaries of force. His arc centers on the cost of advocating hardline justice for the sake of order.

A member of The Elite whose power surges enable brute-force clashes with Superman. He embodies the aggressive, high-impact approach the group uses to override opposition, contributing to the ethical debate about what constitutes protection versus domination. His actions intensify the struggle over when violence is justified.

Part of The Elite, Menagerie brings a dangerous, multifaceted power set to the team. She adds complexity to the debate over control and responsibility, challenging Superman’s insistence on non-lethal methods with her own form of decisive action. Her presence complicates the moral calculus of the conflict.

The Hat contributes cunning and tactical intelligence to The Elite’s operations. He helps drive the group’s plans and moral ambiguity, illustrating how strategy and manipulation can influence the course of a global crisis. His role underscores the ethical stakes of leadership under pressure.

A dangerous antagonist whose imprisonment ends with a breakout, triggering brutal confrontations with The Elite. The decision to execute him for what is framed as peace raises critical questions about pre-emptive violence and the price of preventing catastrophe. His arc tests Superman’s commitment to civilian protection over punitive expediency.

A sharp-eyed journalist who embodies the civilian perspective on the unfolding crisis. Her reporting and public-facing voice anchor the narrative in real-world consequences, reminding viewers that actions in the name of security affect everyday people. She represents the informed public that questions the moral cost of extraordinary measures.