Sherlock: Many Happy Returns

A Buddhist ceremony in the Himalayas unfolds under a hooded abbot, who moves along a line of monks and repeats the Tibetan greeting “Tashi Dalek” to each one. He pauses at the last monk, pulls back the hood, and reveals a blonde drug smuggler, hinting at a persona far more famous than a simple ascetic. In this moment, the abbot’s true identity is invoked as Sherlock Holmes in disguise, casting a shadow of doubt and intrigue over the scene.

“Tashi Dalek,” he says to each monk.

In a dim pub, an aging Anderson Jonathan Aris has just relayed this peculiar case to DI Greg Lestrade Rupert Graves, arguing that the abbot bore the hallmarks of Sherlock Holmes—a man said to possess extraordinary powers of observation. Greg counters that the claim isn’t persuasive, since Sherlock is supposedly dead after the fall from St Bartholomew’s Hospital. Anderson presses the point, mentioning the New Delhi Incident as part of a larger pattern, and insists that Sherlock could not stay away from a mystery, even from beyond the grave.

Inspector Prakash James Pimenta is also dealing with the glare of paparazzi as he recounts the case, suggesting that the solution might hinge on a minute detail—the exact distance a chocolate flake sinks into an ice-cream cone. He steps outside to meet a mysterious man who seems to be listening in, and the exchange hints that the resolution may belong to someone who refuses credit for their cleverness. The tension in the pub makes it clear that Anderson believes only Sherlock could have solved a case this precise, while Greg remains skeptical but unsettled, aware that Sherlock’s influence lingers.

As the conversation deepens, a foreman on a jury asks whether Herr Trepoff is guilty of murdering his wife. Eleven jurors say no, but one mysterious juror votes differently, altering the outcome and making headlines that the “mysterious juror” swayed public opinion. Anderson persists in his conviction that the elusive figure is Sherlock, yet Greg grows more doubtful. He then reveals that Anderson lost his job after obsessing about Sherlock, a detail that leads him to depart the pub and seek out John Watson.

With a map laid out, Anderson points to locations that suggest Sherlock is moving closer to London, heightening the sense that the enigmatic mastermind might reappear. Later, Greg visits John’s house, bringing a box of Sherlock’s possessions that had been left at his office. Among them is a DVD and an uncut version of John’s birthday message from Sherlock, a tangible link to the threads that bind their fates together.

Back at John’s place, John pours a glass of whiskey and decides to run the DVD. The screen lights up with Sherlock on camera at 221B Baker Street, preparing his birthday message and rechecking his excuses, crafting a new ending for the moment. John privately wishes that Sherlock were not dead, and as Sherlock speaks his message, John hesitates at the door, wondering who might be on the other side. The wall between absence and presence trembles as the footage plays, and the moment hints at a surprising return.

In the pub, Anderson smiles at the prospect of Sherlock’s return, while Greg glances at a newspaper bearing the headline The Game is Back On, a sardonic nod to the revived mystique. And when the DVD finally loops in John’s house, the screen shows Sherlock smiling and winking at the camera, a quiet, knowing gesture that hints at a smarter, unseen play about to unfold.

Last Updated: October 01, 2025 at 10:24